|
Question 813821: A,B, and C could finish a job alone in 5 hours. The three started together at 8AM but B rested at 9AM and resumed working at 9:30 AM. At what time they will finish the work?
Found 2 solutions by ankor@dixie-net.com, Edwin McCravy: Answer by ankor@dixie-net.com(22740) (Show Source): Answer by Edwin McCravy(20066) (Show Source):
You can put this solution on YOUR website! A,B, and C could finish a job alone in 5 hours. The three started together at 8AM but B rested at 9AM and resumed working at 9:30 AM. At what time they will finish the work?
The other tutor with his equation
t/5 + (t-.5)/5 + t/5 = 1
is wrong, first because the first term
should be 1/5, not t/5, because from 8 till 9
is 1 hour, not t hours. His second term is
wrong because B was not working during that
half hour from 9 till 9:30, so he couldn't use
1/5. The last term is wrong because it is not
known that they worked as long after 9:30 as
they worked before 9.
It is not known how long it would takes B working
alone to do the job. This is another variable.
If B takes x hours to do the job, then he does
1/xths of the joh in one hour. So if B had been
working that half hour instead of resting, they
would have completed (1/2)(1/5) or 1/(10)ths of
the job during that half hour. However, since B
didn't work during that half hour we must subtract
the portion of the job he would have done, which
is (1/2)(1/x) = 1/(2x) so from 9:00 to 9:30 A and C
only did [1/10 - 1/(2x)] = (2x-10)/(2x) = 2(x-5)/(2x)
= (x-5)/x of the job.
was done.
Now we don't know how long it will take after 9:30
to finish the job, for that depends on how fast B
works. So we have to use another unknown
for that, y hours. Let y = the time after 9:30 that
it takes all three to finish the job.
1/5 + (x-5)/x + y/5 = 1
That simplifies to
y = (25-x)/x
There is not enough information to give just
one possible answer. There are many possible
answers. Here's why.
Suppose B is such a slow worker that it would
take him a long time to do the whole job by
himself (maybe it would even take him as long
as 10 years!) So A and B would do virtually all
the work. B's contribution to the work effort
of the A,B,C team is practically nothing. So
without B, the pair or workers A and C could
virtually do the job in a tiny bit over 5 hours
and finish at a tiny bit after 1:00PM.
It wouldn't matter about B resting, since he
works so slow in this case.
Now look at another extreme case. Suppose B
is the fast worker and it takes A and C ten
years to do the job. So it's practically the
same as if B works 1/5th of the job in the
hour from 8 till 9, rests for a half hour
and does the remaining 4/5th of a job in 4
hours. He'd lose the half hour he rested,
and finish at a little after 1:30PM.
Let's take an intermediate case, where A,B, and
C all three work at the same rate. Then it would
take each 3 times as long to do the job alone or
3×5 or 15 hours each to do it alone.
So from 8:00AM till 9:00AM, they do 3 fifteenths
or 3/15ths of the job. Then in the 1/2 hour from
9:00 till 9:30, they do
(1/2)(2/15) = 1/15 of the job. So that's a total
of 4/15ths of the job at 9:30AM. They still have
11/15ths of the job left to do, and since they can
do 3/15ths in one hour it will take them
(11/15)÷(3/15) or 11/3 or 3 2/3 hours to finish.
That's 3 hours and 20 minutes after 9:30AM so
they'll finish at 12:50AM.
So there are many possibiloities. Check the problem
again. I'll bet something was left out. But don't
go with the other tutor's solution.
Edwin
|
|
|
| |