cos(A) + cos(B) + cos(C) =
Let A=P+Q
and B=P-Q
(with hopes of showing that Q=0)
Then A+B = 2P and
A-B = 2Q
A+B+C = 180°
C = 180°-(A+B)
C = 180°-2P
Substituting in the given equation:
cos(P+Q)+cos(P-Q)+cos(180°-2P) =
cos(P+Q) + cos(P-Q) - cos(2P) =
We write an identity for each term on the left
and add the three equations:
cos(P+Q) = cos(P)cos(Q)-sin(P)sin(Q)
cos(P+Q) = cos(P)cos(Q)+sin(P)sin(Q)
-cos(2P) = -[2cosē(P)-1]
------------------------------------
= 2cos(P)cos(Q)-2cosē(P)+1
Clear the fraction:
3 = 4cos(P)cos(Q)-4cosē(P)+2
Rearrange the equation with 0 on the right:
4cosē(P) - 4cos(Q)cos(P) + 1 = 0
That is a quadratic equation in cos(P).
Its solution(s) must be real so the
discriminant must be ≧ 0
bē-4ac ≧ 0
16cosē(Q)-16 ≧ 0
16(cosē(Q)-1) ≧ 0
cosē(Q)-1 ≧ 0
cosē(Q) ≧ 1
The square of a cosine is never > 1
Therefore
cosē(Q) = 1
cos(Q) = ą1
Q = 0° or 180°
A-B = 2Q
A and B cannot differ by 2(180°) or 360° so they
must differ by 0°, so Q=0°, so
A-B=0
A=B
Now if we interchange B and C throughout the
above, we will get A=C. So the three angles are
equal and thus the triangle is equilateral.
Edwin