Question 6647:  Dear Sir/Madam, 
 
I am confronted with the following problem: 
 
"Find the equation of the line that is tangent to the circle x^2 + y^2 = 25 at the point P(-3,4)." 
 
I did the following: 
1)   
2)   
3) f'(x) =   
4) f'(-3) =   
5)   
6) -3(x + 3) = 4(y - 4) 
7) -3x - 9 = 4y - 16 
8) 4y = -3x + 7 
9)   which should be the equation of the tangent.
 
Instead however,   is the equation of the tangent. Why? 
Thanks in advance. 
Regards, 
-Mike 
 Found 2 solutions by  rapaljer, Mike: Answer by rapaljer(4671)      (Show Source): 
You can  put this solution on YOUR website! Your problem is in step 2, where you solved for y by taking the square root of both sides of the equation.  You must include a "+ or -" symbol in this step, where the plus or the minus is determined by the point that is selected.  What you have is the equation of a circle, and the point of tangency is at (-3,4) placing the point in the second quadrant, since x is negative and y is positive.  Notice that in the second quadrant, the slope of a tangent line to a point on the curve will have a positive slope (by inspection!), so you have to use the plus sign for the slope of the tangent line.  In quadrant IV, where x is positive and y is negative, you also have a positive slope.  In quadrants I and III, the tangent line to a circle will  have a negative slope (again by inspection!).
 
 
I think the rest of what you have done is correct.
 
 
R^2 at SCC 
 Answer by Mike(39)      (Show Source): 
  | 
 
  
 
 |   
 
 |