| 
 
 
| Question 217905:  The lengths of the sides of a triangle are all whole numbers.  The triangle has a perimeter (distance around the shape) of M units.  If someone gives you a value for M, determine the shortest possible length of a side.
 
 this is a problem my teacher asigned us for the wekkend i have worked on it for two hourrs but nothing is making sense. im not sure what to do at all. PLEASE HELP ME
 Found 2 solutions by  checkley77, scott8148:
 Answer by checkley77(12844)
      (Show Source): 
You can put this solution on YOUR website! YOU DIDN'T STATE THAT THIS TRIANGLE IS A RIGHT TRIANGLE OR NOT. IT DOES MAKE A DIFFERENCE.
 PERIMETER (M)=A+B+C FOR ALL TRIANGLES.
 LET M=12
 A RIGHT TRIANGLE COULD BE:
 3+4+5=12
 BECAUSE 3^3+4^2=5^2
 9+16=25
 25=25 THUS THE SMALLER SIDE WOULD BE 3.
 HOWEVER A NON-RIGHT TRIANGLE WOULD HAVE A DIFFERENT SOLUTION GIVEN AN (M) VALUE.
 TRY (M)=47
 THE SHORTEST SIDE COULD BE 1.
 A+B+C=47
 1+B+C=47
 1+23+23=47 (THIS TECHNIQUE WORKS AS LONG AS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE B & C SIDES IS < THE A SIDE.)
 47=47
 THIS WORKS FOR ANY PERIMETER = AN ODD NUMBER.
 LETS TRY AN EVEN NUMBER:
 (M)=74
 A+B+C=74
 2+B+C=74
 2+36+34=74 (AGAIN THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN B & C IS < A SIDE.)
 74=74
 
Answer by scott8148(6628)
      (Show Source): 
You can put this solution on YOUR website! the sides are all whole numbers (so M must also be a whole number) 
 the smallest (non-zero) whole number is 1
 
 in a triangle, the sum of any two sides must be greater than the third side; otherwise the triangle doesn't "close up"
 
 so 3 is the smallest possible value for M ___ with a side of 1
 
 M=4 doesn't close ___ 1+1 is NOT greater than 2
 
 M=5 ; 2, 2, 1
 
 M=6 ; 3, 2, 1 doesn't close ___ but 2, 2, 2 works
 
 M=7 ; 3, 3, 1
 
 M=8 ; 4, 3, 1 doesn't close ___ but 3, 3, 2 works
 
 it looks like:
 ___ if M is odd, then the shortest side is 1
 ___ if M is even (except for 4), then the shortest side is 2
 | 
  
 | 
 |