SOLUTION: 3x/9x-15 This is what I did 3x/9x-15 1x/3x-15 1/3-15=-44/3

Algebra ->  Polynomials-and-rational-expressions -> SOLUTION: 3x/9x-15 This is what I did 3x/9x-15 1x/3x-15 1/3-15=-44/3      Log On


   



Question 181648This question is from textbook
: 3x/9x-15
This is what I did
3x/9x-15
1x/3x-15
1/3-15=-44/3
This question is from textbook

Found 2 solutions by eperette, solver91311:
Answer by eperette(173) About Me  (Show Source):
You can put this solution on YOUR website!
There is two different ways to look at this problem here....
(1) (3x/9x)-15 or
(2) (3x)/(9x-15)
notice that in the first one the only numbers underneath the division sign are 9x while in the second one it is assumed that you have (9x-15) under the division sign...
your solution is correct if the problem is like (1) but if problem is like (2) you cannot separate the denominator...
(2) http://www.algebra.com/algebra/homework/Polynomials-and-rational-expressions/Polynomials-and-rational-expressions.faq.question.181645.html

Answer by solver91311(24713) About Me  (Show Source):
You can put this solution on YOUR website!


You might be correct. It all depends on what you meant by 3x/9x-15.

If you meant:



Then you are absolutely correct.

On the other hand, if you meant:



Then you have a bit of a problem with your process. You cannot separate the terms in a polynomial numerator or denominator and then operate with the separated terms individually. Let me demonstrate on this problem with a couple of simple substitutions:

Let x = 1, then



or let x = 2, then



What you can do with this problem is factor out the 3 that is common to both the numerator and both terms of the denominator and then eliminate it, thus:



And that is as much as you can do with this expression, except to make sure you restrict the value of x such that because that value would make the denominator equal 0.

John