| 
 
 
| Question 1197567:  An airplane averages 150 mph. If a trip from Atlanta to Charleston takes 2 hours 48 minutes going against the wind, and 2 hours on on the return flight going with the wind, what is the speed of the wind
 Found 4 solutions by  math_tutor2020, greenestamps, josgarithmetic, ikleyn:
 Answer by math_tutor2020(3817)
      (Show Source): 
You can put this solution on YOUR website! w = speed of the wind in mph
 
 2 hrs + 48 min = 2 hrs + (48/60) hrs
 2 hrs + 48 min = 2 hrs + 0.8 hrs
 2 hrs + 48 min = 2.8 hrs
 
 150-w = speed of the plane going against the wind
 distance = rate*time
 distance = (150-w)*2.8
 distance = 420-2.8w
 
 150+w = speed of the plane going with the wind
 distance = rate*time
 distance = (150+w)*2
 distance = 300+2w
 
 The distance is same each time because the plane is following the same route, when going from  Atlanta to Charleston then back from Charleston to Atlanta.
 
 Because the distance is the same for each equation, we can equate the right hand sides and solve for w.
 420-2.8w = 300+2w
 420-300 = 2w+2.8w
 120 = 4.8w
 w = 120/4.8
 w = 25
 The speed of the wind is 25 mph
 
 Check:
 If the plane goes against the wind, then its speed is 150-w = 150-25 = 125 mph.
 Traveling for 2.8 hours means it covers a distance of 125*2.8 = 350 miles
 If the plane goes with the wind, then its speed is 150+w = 150+25 = 175 mph.
 Traveling for 2 hours gives a distance of 175*2 = 350 miles.
 We get the same distance each time to help confirm the answer.
 
 Answer: 25 mph
 
Answer by greenestamps(13209)
      (Show Source): Answer by josgarithmetic(39630)
      (Show Source): Answer by ikleyn(52878)
      (Show Source): 
You can put this solution on YOUR website! . 
 The solution by @josgarithmetic is conceptually  TOTALLY  wrong.
 
 It is wrong,  since this airplane averages  150 mph in  STILL  AIR
 (the part of the condition,  which is
  in the post). 
 Again :   150 mph is the average speed of the plane in  STILL  AIR,
 but  NOT  IN  THIS  round trip:  150 mph relates to  TOTALLY  DIFFERENT  conception.
 
 
 The post itself has a  HUGE  DEFICIENCY:  it missed
 to determine correctly all the participating values/conditions.
 
 
 Taking it into the consideration, the problem, as it is worded in the post,
 is ambiguous, which is not allowed for Math problems.
 
 
 Therefore,  my advise to the visitor is to throw this  " problem "  to the closest garbage bin
 and to
  that only mathematically correct problems are the subject of consideration at this forum. 
 
 Each correct mathematical problem is a piece of art.
 What is not piece of art - is not a correct mathematical problem.
 
 
 Exactly as the wife of an emperor should be beyond suspicions,
 every  Math problem must be ideally and absolutely correct - always.
 
 
 
 | 
  
 | 
 |