SOLUTION: a company tests its workers with a lie-detector that is correct 90% of the time and fires anyone fail the test suppose 5% of the workers are guilty of theft 1- for the workers w

Algebra ->  Probability-and-statistics -> SOLUTION: a company tests its workers with a lie-detector that is correct 90% of the time and fires anyone fail the test suppose 5% of the workers are guilty of theft 1- for the workers w      Log On


   



Question 1187758: a company tests its workers with a lie-detector that is correct 90% of the time and fires anyone fail the test suppose 5% of the workers are guilty of theft
1- for the workers who are fired ,calculate the percentage of them are actually guilty ?

Answer by ikleyn(52919) About Me  (Show Source):
You can put this solution on YOUR website!
.
a company tests its workers with a lie-detector that is correct 90% of the time and fires anyone
fail the test suppose 5% of the workers are guilty of theft.
1) for the workers who are fired, calculate the percentage of them are actually guilty ?
~~~~~~~~~~~~


The problem seems to be tangled,  but it is because it is  (intently ?)  formulated in a way
to confuse the reader.

I will reformulate it,  and then everything will become clear as at a sunny day.

    a company tests its workers with a lie-detector. The device is correct in 90% cases,
    which means that if it recognizes/detects  lie/theft  in  100 cases,  then in 90 cases it is right.
    Let the amount of people recognized as liers is 5% of the work force.
    Among this 5% people, detected as liers, what is the percentage of those who are actually guilty ?

After my re-formulation,  the   ANSWER   is as clear as   2 x 2 = 4:

    90% of these 5% are actually guilty.

    Or, in other words,  0.9*0.05 = 0.045 = 4.5% of total workers are actually guilty.


Solved,  answered and explained.


/////////////


More advanced reader will notice that we are given the  conditional probability


        P%28_lier_%29%2FP%28_detected_as_a_lier%29 = 90% = 0.9             (*)


and also are given that   P(detected as a lier) = 0.05.


The question is to find   P ( lier ).


Then from  (*),  we get the answer/answers formulated above.