SOLUTION: For each of the following statements, explain why it is true for all functions f and g or an example of specific functions f and g showing that it is false. a. All elements in t

Algebra ->  Customizable Word Problem Solvers  -> Misc -> SOLUTION: For each of the following statements, explain why it is true for all functions f and g or an example of specific functions f and g showing that it is false. a. All elements in t      Log On

Ad: Over 600 Algebra Word Problems at edhelper.com


   



Question 1186928: For each of the following statements, explain why it is true for all functions f and g or an example of specific functions f and g showing that it is false.
a. All elements in the domain of g must be in the domain of f o g (fog)
b. All elements in the range of f must be in the range of f o g

Found 2 solutions by CPhill, ikleyn:
Answer by CPhill(1987) About Me  (Show Source):
You can put this solution on YOUR website!
Let's analyze each statement:
**a. All elements in the domain of *g* must be in the domain of *f o g***
**True.**
*Explanation:* The composition *f o g* (or *f(g(x))*) is defined as applying the function *g* first, and then applying the function *f* to the result. For *f(g(x))* to be defined, *g(x)* *must* be defined. This means that *x* must be in the domain of *g*. If *x* is not in the domain of *g*, then *g(x)* is undefined, and therefore *f(g(x))* is also undefined. So, any *x* in the domain of *f o g* *must* also be in the domain of *g*.
**b. All elements in the range of *f* must be in the range of *f o g***
**False.**
*Counterexample:*
Let *f(x) = x²*. The range of *f* is [0, ∞).
Let *g(x) = x + 1*.
Then *(f o g)(x) = f(g(x)) = f(x + 1) = (x + 1)²*. The range of *f o g* is also [0, ∞).
However, let's consider a slightly different g(x)
Let *f(x) = x²*. The range of *f* is [0, ∞).
Let *g(x) = 0*.
Then *(f o g)(x) = f(g(x)) = f(0) = 0²=0*. The range of *f o g* is just {0}.
In this case, the range of *f* is [0, ∞), but the range of *f o g* is only {0}. Therefore, not all elements in the range of *f* are in the range of *f o g*.
In general, the range of *f o g* is a *subset* of the range of *f*. It can be smaller, but not larger.

Answer by ikleyn(52835) About Me  (Show Source):
You can put this solution on YOUR website!
.
For each of the following statements, explain why it is true for all functions f and g or an example of specific functions f and g showing that it is false.
a. All elements in the domain of g must be in the domain of f o g (fog)
b. All elements in the range of f must be in the range of f o g
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~


In the post by  @CPhill  (Artificial  Intelligence  ?),   the answer  " True "  in part  (a)  is a   highlight%28highlight%28FATAL%29%29   highlight%28highlight%28ERROR%29%29.


Counter-example:   g(x) = x;   f(x) = 1%2Fx.

Then  x = 0  is in the domain of  g,   but is  NOT  in the domain of   (fog)(x) = 1%2Fx.


By the way, it means that all the argumentation of @CPhill in part  (a)  is invalid,
although it produces quite solid impression.


A stern examiner would give a solid  " highlight%28highlight%282%29%29 "  to such an  " artificial intelligence "  student.


But remember,  that an  " artificial intelligence"  claims not to be  " a student ",
but to be a  " SUPERIOR  MIND ",  who does not make mistakes,  knows everything
and leads everybody around to a bright future  ( ! )


What I want to say is that still there are plenty of the room to improve your skills
as an "artificial intelligence" before you become a true "Artificial Intelligence".