SOLUTION: Among 140 middle school students, 90 like chocolate ice cream, 70 like strawberry ice cream, and 55 like both. A middle school student is randomly selected. Is liking chocolate

Algebra ->  Probability-and-statistics -> SOLUTION: Among 140 middle school students, 90 like chocolate ice cream, 70 like strawberry ice cream, and 55 like both. A middle school student is randomly selected. Is liking chocolate       Log On


   



Question 1172111: Among 140 middle school students, 90 like chocolate ice cream, 70 like strawberry ice cream, and 55 like both. A middle school student is randomly selected.
Is liking chocolate and strawberry ice cream independent events?

Found 2 solutions by Boreal, ikleyn:
Answer by Boreal(15235) About Me  (Show Source):
You can put this solution on YOUR website!
p(both)=p(c)*p(s) if independent
-
p(c or s)=p(c)+p(s)+p(both),
so putting it in student number
p(c or s)=90+70-55 (55 is double counted)
and 160-55=115 students that like one or the other.
-
so 55/140=(90/140)* (70/140) if independent events
55/140=45/140, which it isn't, so not independent events

Answer by ikleyn(52835) About Me  (Show Source):
You can put this solution on YOUR website!
.

In order for to answer the question, we should check if

    P(c)*Ps) = P(c AND s).


From the condition, we have

    P(c) = 90%2F140 = 9%2F14;  P(s) = 70%2F140 = 1%2F2;   hence,  P(c)*P(s) = %289%2F14%29%2A%281%2F2%29 = 9%2F28.



From the other hand side,

    P(c AND s) = 55%2F140 = 11%2F28.


These calculations show that  P(c)*Ps) =/= P(c AND s);  hence, the events "c" and "s" are NOT INDEPENDENT.

Solved.

--------------

In his post, tutor @Boreal makes many unnecessary calculations, that shade the solution's logic.

So I came with my post to make this logic more clear.