SOLUTION: Suppose Q and S are independent events such that the probability that at least one of them occurs is 1/3 and the probability that Q occurs but S does not occur is 1/9. What is th

Algebra ->  Probability-and-statistics -> SOLUTION: Suppose Q and S are independent events such that the probability that at least one of them occurs is 1/3 and the probability that Q occurs but S does not occur is 1/9. What is th      Log On


   



Question 1151388: Suppose Q and S are independent events such that the probability that
at least one of them occurs is 1/3 and the probability that Q occurs but
S does not occur is 1/9. What is the probability of S?

Found 2 solutions by Edwin McCravy, ikleyn:
Answer by Edwin McCravy(20065) About Me  (Show Source):
You can put this solution on YOUR website!
Suppose Q and S are independent events such that the probability that
at least one of them occurs is 1/3 and the probability that Q occurs but
S does not occur is 1/9. What is the probability of S?
Draw a Venn diagram with two sets, Q and S.  There are 4 regions
for the four possibilities:

Let w = P(Q occurs and not S does not occur)
Let x = P(Q occurs and S occurs)
Let y = P(S occurs and Q does not occur)
Let z = P(Q does not occur and S does not occur)

We put the 4 letters in the corresponding regions:


the probability that Q occurs but S does not occur is 1/9.
 
That is the part of the red circle Q that is not part of the blue
circle, the left part of the red circle Q. So w=1/9. So we put
1/9 in place of w.


the probability that at least one of them occurs is 1/3...
Therefore we have the equation:

1%2F9%2Bx%2By=1%2F3
What is the probability of S?
Since the probability of S is x+y, we can determine that by
solving for x+y:

  <--answer

[We have the answer already. We did not need to use that they are independent.
In fact as it turns out, they could NOT be independent!!]

Edwin

Answer by ikleyn(52914) About Me  (Show Source):
You can put this solution on YOUR website!
.

I don't know what is the source of this problem,  who created it and where is it came from,

but the assumption that the events  P  and  S  are independent  CONTRADICTS  to the rest of the post.


The situation described in the post,  NEVER  may happen,  and in this sense,  the problem is  DEFECTIVE
(= is fake problem,  in simple terms).

So, if you want to have a correctly posed problem,  take off this assumption that the events  P  and  S  are independent.


-----------------

And be careful in creating problems, when and if you don't know the subject and the terminology . . .