SOLUTION: In a classroom, two-third of the students are wearing blue jeans and three-fourth of those students are wearing T-shirts. How many students are wearing jeans and a T-shirt? show wo

Algebra ->  Test -> SOLUTION: In a classroom, two-third of the students are wearing blue jeans and three-fourth of those students are wearing T-shirts. How many students are wearing jeans and a T-shirt? show wo      Log On


   



Question 1131586: In a classroom, two-third of the students are wearing blue jeans and three-fourth of those students are wearing T-shirts. How many students are wearing jeans and a T-shirt? show work.
Found 3 solutions by greenestamps, Edwin McCravy, Alan3354:
Answer by greenestamps(13200) About Me  (Show Source):
You can put this solution on YOUR website!


number of students in the class: x

number wearing blue jeans (two-thirds of the students): (2/3)x

number wearing t-shirts (three-fourths of those wearing blue jeans): (3/4)((2/3)x) = (3/4)(2/3)x = (1/2)x

ANSWER: half of the students are wearing blue jeans and t-shirts.

=========================================================

To tutor @EdwinMcCravy --

It is beneath you to post a response like that, saying that my answer is wrong.

You provide many good responses to readers' questions. Leave it to some other tutors who consistently pronounce that another tutor's solution is wrong and that theirs (usually shown without any work!) is the only right answer. We unfortunately have enough of them working on this site.

I strongly disagree with your reading of the problem. The statement of the problem says that two-thirds of the students are wearing blue jeans and three-fourths of THOSE students are wearing t-shirts. As I read it, that's a different problem than just saying that two-thirds of the students are wearing blue jeans and three-fourths of the students are wearing t-shirts.

If you have a different interpretation of the problem than I have, then say so. Don't tell the reader that my solution is wrong.


Answer by Edwin McCravy(20056) About Me  (Show Source):
You can put this solution on YOUR website!
THE ABOVE SOLUTION IS WRONG!  It's 5/12ths of the students

Let J = the set of students wearing jeans
Let T = the set of students wearing T-shirts

Let x = the number wearing jeans but not T-shirts = N(J∩T')
Let y = the number wearing both jeans and a T-shirt = N(J∩T)
Let z = the number wearing T-shirts but not jeans = N(J'∩T)

N(J) = N(J∩T') + N(J∩T) = x+y
N(T) = N(J∩T) + N(J'∩T) = y+z

This is the Venn diagram:




So system%28x%2By=expr%282%2F3%29n%2Cy%2Bz=expr%283%2F4%29n%29

After clearing of fractions:

system%283%28x%2By%29=2n%2C4%28y%2Bz%29=4n%29

This says that n must be divisible by both 3 and 4, so n must be
divisible by 12, so n = 12k

Since two-third of the students are wearing blue jeans,
2/3 of 12k = 8k are wearing blue jeans.

Since three-fourths of the students are wearing T-shirts,
3/4 of 12k = 9k are wearing T-shirts.

N(J or T) = N(J) + N(T) - N(J and T)

       12k = 8k + 9k - N(J and T)

       12k = 17k - N(J and T)

N(X and Y) = 5k

So 5k students are wearing both jeans and T-shirts.

So there are many solutions depending upon the choice of k:

Since there are 8k students in set J, the blue circle, and 5k students
in the overlapping part of the two circles, there must be 8k-5k or 3k
in the left part of the blue circle.

Similarly, since there are 9k students in set T, the red circle, and 5k
students in the overlapping part of the two circles, there must be 9k-5k 
or 4k in the right part of the blue circle.



Since there are 5k students wearing both, out of 3k+5k+4k=12k students,
the answer is always 5/12 of the students. 

The smallest possible solution is when k=0, no students at all in the
classroom, 0 wearing blue jeans, and 0 wearing T-shirts. That is a
possibility because 0 is both 2/3rds as well as 3/4ths of 0.  Also 5/12ths
of zero is zero. It's probably not the solution your teacher wanted, but
mathematically it fits.

The next smallest possible solution is when k=1, 



In that case, there are 12 students in the classroom, 8 wearing blue jeans
and 9 wearing T-shirts. That is a possibility because 8 is 2/3rds of 12 and
9 is 3/4ths of 12. The answer is 5 wearing both, which is 5/12ths of 12. 

The next smallest possible solution is when k=2



In that case, there are 24 students in the classroom, 16 wearing blue jeans
and 18 wearing T-shirts. That is a possibility because 16 is 2/3rds of 24 
and 18 is 3/4ths of 24. The answer is 10 wearing both, which is 5/12ths of 24. 

The next smallest possible solution is when k=3



In that case, there are 36 students in the classroom, 24 wearing blue jeans
and 27 wearing T-shirts. That is a possibility because 24 is 2/3rds of 36 
and 27 is 3/4ths of 36. The answer is 15 wearing both, which is 5/12ths of 36. 

We can let k be any integer and get a different solution.  The solution
in every case will be 5k, a multiple of 5.

Edwin

Answer by Alan3354(69443) About Me  (Show Source):
You can put this solution on YOUR website!
A minor point:
It's not 5/12ths.
It's either 5/12, or 5 12ths.
==============
PS - We all make mistakes. If a tutor makes a mistake, it can be educational. The student can locate the mistake and learn from it.
I don't think a person working for no pay to assist someone he/she doesn't know should be insulted or treated rudely by another person.
----
I'm more concerned that too often the tutors do the problem for the student, and the student gets the answer and moves on, learning nothing.