SOLUTION: If x and y are positive integers and x+y <9, how many different values are there for the product xy?

Algebra ->  Coordinate Systems and Linear Equations  -> Linear Equations and Systems Word Problems -> SOLUTION: If x and y are positive integers and x+y <9, how many different values are there for the product xy?      Log On


   



Question 1111132: If x and y are positive integers and x+y <9, how many different values are there for the product xy?
Found 2 solutions by Alan3354, math_helper:
Answer by Alan3354(69443) About Me  (Show Source):
You can put this solution on YOUR website!
If x and y are positive integers and x+y <9, how many different values are there for the product xy?
===========
Five. if x <> y and zero is not used.

Answer by math_helper(2461) About Me  (Show Source):
You can put this solution on YOUR website!
If you build a table of the set {1} U {Primes less than 9} you can get unique products.
For each line of the table, consider the sum x+y<9 and filter appropriately by looking at earlier lines to ensure that number combination has not been covered already. The only additional tricky part is
you must consider powers of x and y that are greater than 1:

x y
1 1,2,3,5,7, 4 ( 4=2%5E2 )
2 3,4,5
3 3,4,5
5 none
7 none
4 4

覧覧覧覧
That's 13 unique products (1,2,3,5,7,4, 6,8,10, 9,12,15, 16)
覧覧覧覧
Tutor Alan3354's answer is incorrect, even with his assumptions. He's made an assumption about +x+%3C%3E+y+ which is not stated in the problem. Also, x,y not equal to zero is implied by the question ("positive integers" excludes 0. Remember that: zero is neither positive nor is it negative).
覧覧覧覧覧覧覧
Reply to the student: a 'table' is just a list of values (did you ever make a multiplication table?). In my case, I listed x values in one column and corresponding values of y that go with that value of x. So looking at the first row: x is 1, y can take on 1, 2,3,5,7, and 4, giving products xy = 1,2,3,5,7, and 4, respectively.
I listed primes because the Fundamental Theorem of Arithmetic says any number can be written as the product of a unique number of prime numbers (if you don't know this theorem, look it up and learn it).
Thus, a unique product of primes (including repeats, or powers > 1) is a unique number. The 'filtering' I refer to is this: one must be careful not to just reverse the order and think its a new number (e.g. row 2 has x=2, y=3 which will produce 6, so in row for x=3 you don't want to list y=2 because 3*2 =6 which is just the result of a trivial reversal of x and y).
Remember, in building the table, I had the following criteria in mind:
1. x and y must be positive integers (that mean x and y are both integers greater than zero)
2. x+y < 9, this was a restriction in the question you posted.
3. xy is a unique product (so one doesn't treat yx like its different than xy).

Notice in my answer I have provided spaces to help correlate back to the row from which those products came.
覧覧覧覧覧覧
Examples of the Fundamental Theorem of Arithmetic (FTArith):
5 = 5 (5 is a prime number, only 1 and 5 divide evenly into 5) NOTE: 1 is NOT prime.
14 = 2*7 (FTArith says 14 can ONLY be broken down to 2*7, no other product of primes will give you 14)
28 = 2%5E2%2A7+
56 = 2%5E3%2A7+
53352 = +2%5E3%2A3%5E2%2A13%2A19+
10 = 2*5
100 = +2%5E2%2A5%5E2+
1000 = +2%5E3%2A5%5E3+