Question 1104538: . I had pancakes for breakfast today. I had pancakes for breakfast today and God infallibly foreknows the future, only if God believed a million years ago that I would have pancakes for breakfast today. If God believed a million years ago that I would have pancakes for breakfast today, then, if I could have chosen to have something else, either I could have brought it about that God did not believe a million years ago that I would have pancakes for breakfast today or I could have brought it about that God had a false belief. However, if God believed a million years ago that I would have pancakes for breakfast today, then, if I could have brought it about that God did not believe a million years ago that I would have pancakes for breakfast today, I could have changed the past. But I could not have changed the past. Also, it’s false that, if God infallibly foreknows the future, I could have brought it about that God had a false belief. Therefore, if God infallibly knows the future, I could not have chosen to have something else. (P: I had pancakes today; I: God infallibly foreknows the future; B: God believed a million years ago that I would have pancakes today; C: I could have chosen to have something else; Y: I could have brought it about that God did not believe a million years ago that I would have pancakes today; F: I could have brought it about that God had a false belief; H: I could have changed the past.
I have spent hours on this. You have to translate it then solve it by assuming the conditional proof or buy assuming RAA. I can't figure out the proper translation for it. Any help is very much appreciated I have a final exam in 1 hour.
Answer by Alan3354(69443)   (Show Source):
|
|
|
