SOLUTION: If a cube has an edge equal to the diagonal of another cube. Find the ratio of their volumes

Algebra ->  Volume -> SOLUTION: If a cube has an edge equal to the diagonal of another cube. Find the ratio of their volumes       Log On


   



Question 1015275: If a cube has an edge equal to the diagonal of another cube. Find the ratio of their volumes
Found 2 solutions by rothauserc, Edwin McCravy:
Answer by rothauserc(4718) About Me  (Show Source):
You can put this solution on YOUR website!
I assume your cube's diagonal is not a space diagonal
**********************************************************
let e1 be an edge of cube 1, then volume of cube 1 is e1^3
We know that e1 is the diagonal of cube 2, let e2 be an edge of cube
:
now use the Pythagorean Theorem
e1^2 = e2^2 + e2^2
2e2^2 = e1^2
e2 = e1/sqrt(2)
volume of cube 2 is e1^3 / (sqrt(2))^3 = e1^3 / (2sqrt(2))
:
the ratio(R) of their volumes is e1^3 / (e1^3 / (2sqrt(2)))
R = (e1^3 * 2sqrt(2)) / e1^3 = 2sqrt(2)
:
***********************************************
The other tutor's solution uses the space diagonal, I did not use that since the problem stated "diagonal" only.
It should be clear that a cube has two types of diagonals, one is on a face and the other is inside - called a space diagonal.

Answer by Edwin McCravy(20060) About Me  (Show Source):
You can put this solution on YOUR website!
The other tutor's solution above is incorrect.
 


Let x be the length of every edge of the smaller cube.

ΔABC and ΔBCE are right triangles. (They don't look it 
because they're drawn in perspective to make a 2D drawing 
look like 3D.)  But ∠ACB is the right angle in right 
triangle ΔABC, and ∠BCE is the right angle in right
triangle ΔBCE.

BC is the hypotenuse of right triangle ΔABC, and it is
also the bottom leg of triangle ABC,

Using the Pythagorean theorem on right triangle ΔABC:

AB%5E2%2BAC%5E2=BC%5E2
x%5E2%2Bx%5E2=BC%5E2
2x%5E2=BC%5E2
  
Using the Pythagorean theorem on right triangle ΔABC:

BC%5E2%2BCE%5E2=BE%5E2
2x%5E2%2Bx%5E2=d%5E2
3x%5E2=d%5E2
sqrt%283x%5E2%29=d
x%2Asqrt%283%29=d
x=d%2Fsqrt%283%29

Using the volume of a cube formula for the smaller cube: 

V+=+edge%5E3
V+=+x%5E3
V+=+%28d%2Fsqrt%283%29%29%5E3

Using the volume of a cube formula for the larger cube:
V+=+edge%5E3
V+=+d%5E3

The ratio of the volume of the larger cube to the volume
of the smaller cube:

matrix%281%2C3%2Cd%5E3%2C%22%3A%22%2C%28d%2Fsqrt%283%29%29%5E3%29

or the fraction:

d%5E3%2F%28d%2Fsqrt%283%29%29%5E3%29%22%22=%22%22d%5E3%2F%28%28d%5E3%2Fsqrt%283%29%5E3%29%29%29%22%22=%22%22d%5E3%22%22%2A%22%22%28%28sqrt%283%29%5E3%29%2Fd%5E3%29%29%22%22=%22%22sqrt%283%29%5E3 to 1

So the volume of the larger cube is sqrt%283%29%5E3 or about 5.2 times
the volume of the smaller cube.
Edwin