SOLUTION: Bob can plant a garden by her self in 10 hours. When her son Andrew helps her the total time it takes them to plant the garden is 4 hours. How long would it take Andrew to plant th
Algebra ->
Rate-of-work-word-problems
-> SOLUTION: Bob can plant a garden by her self in 10 hours. When her son Andrew helps her the total time it takes them to plant the garden is 4 hours. How long would it take Andrew to plant th
Log On
Question 1131129: Bob can plant a garden by her self in 10 hours. When her son Andrew helps her the total time it takes them to plant the garden is 4 hours. How long would it take Andrew to plant the garden himself Found 3 solutions by josgarithmetic, ikleyn, greenestamps:Answer by josgarithmetic(39617) (Show Source):
Working together, Bob and Andrew make of the job per hour.
Working alone, Bob makes of the job per hour.
Hence, working alone, Andrew makes - = = of the job per hour.
It means that Andrew needs hours = hours = 6 hours and 40 minutes to complete the job working alone. Answer
Solved.
-------------------
The lessons to learn from this solution :
1) You can solve this problem/(such problems) even without using equations.
Freely manipulating with fractions is enough.
2) Use the notion "rate of work" and remember:
a) when two persons work together, their combined rate of work is the sum of individual rates;
b) when the combined rate of two workers is given along with the rate of one of them, the rate
of the other worker is the difference of combined rate and the given individual rate.
Very simple rules, and they allow to solve MANY OF SIMILAR PROBLEMS.
Here is an alternative to the standard method for solving "working together" problems that the other two tutors have shown.
Consider the least common multiple of the two times given, 4 hours and 10 hours. The least common multiple is 20 hours.
Bob can plant a garden in 10 hours, so in 20 hours she can plant 2 of those gardens.
Together, Bob and her son Andrew can plant the garden in 4 hours, so in 20 hours together they could plant 5 of those gardens.
So in those 20 hours Bob can plant 2 of the gardens, and Bob and Andrew together can plant 5 of them; that means in 20 hours Andrew alone can plant 3 of them.
And so the time Andrew alone takes to plant the one garden is 20/3 hours, or 6 2/3 hours.