1. ~ A V (B & E) 2. ~ A -> ~ C 3. C V (B & D) / B | 4. ~B AIP | 5. ~BV~E 4, Add | 6. ~(B&E) 5, DM | 7. (B&E)V~A 1, Comm | 8. ~A 7,6, DS | 9. ~C 2, MP |10. B&D 3,9, DS |11. B 10, Simp |12. B&~B 11,4, Conj 13. ~~B 4-12 IP 14. B 13, DN Edwin