Question 1210172: Given a regular octagon, in how many ways can we color one diagonal red and another diagonal blue so that the two colored diagonals intersect at an endpoint? Consider rotations and reflections distinct.
Found 2 solutions by CPhill, ikleyn:
Answer by CPhill(1959)   (Show Source):
You can put this solution on YOUR website! Let's break down this problem systematically.
**1. Total Diagonals in an Octagon**
* An octagon has 8 vertices.
* The number of diagonals in an $n$-sided polygon is given by $n(n-3)/2$.
* For an octagon, the number of diagonals is $8(8-3)/2 = 8(5)/2 = 20$.
**2. Choosing the Red Diagonal**
* We can choose any of the 20 diagonals to be red.
**3. Choosing the Blue Diagonal (Intersecting at an Endpoint)**
* Once we've chosen a red diagonal, we need to choose a blue diagonal that intersects it at an endpoint.
* A diagonal has two endpoints.
* For each endpoint of the red diagonal, we need to count how many other diagonals intersect at that endpoint.
* **Case 1: Red Diagonal is a Side-Skipping Diagonal (e.g., skips one vertex)**
* Consider a red diagonal that skips one vertex.
* At each endpoint, there are 3 other diagonals that intersect.
* In total, there are 3 + 3 = 6 diagonals that intersect the red diagonal.
* **Case 2: Red Diagonal is a Diameter-Type Diagonal (e.g., skips three vertices)**
* Consider a red diagonal that skips three vertices.
* At each endpoint, there are 3 other diagonals that intersect.
* In total, there are 3 + 3 = 6 diagonals that intersect the red diagonal.
**4. Counting the Pairs**
* Regardless of the type of red diagonal, there are always 6 diagonals that intersect it at an endpoint.
* So, for each of the 20 red diagonals, we have 6 choices for the blue diagonal.
* Thus, we have $20 \times 6 = 120$ pairs of diagonals.
**5. Accounting for Color Order**
* Since we're coloring one diagonal red and the other blue, the order matters. We need to multiply by 2 to account for the cases where the red and blue diagonals are swapped.
* Total ways = $120 \times 1 = 120$.
**Therefore, there are 120 ways to color one diagonal red and another diagonal blue so that the two colored diagonals intersect at an endpoint.**
Answer by ikleyn(52776)  (Show Source):
You can put this solution on YOUR website! .
Given a regular octagon, in how many ways can we color one diagonal red and another diagonal blue
so that the two colored diagonals intersect at an endpoint? Consider rotations and reflections distinct.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Let's consider any one vertex of the octagon.
The number of diagonals emanating from this vertex is 8 - 3 = 5.
The number of "other" diagonals emanating from this vertex is 5 - 3 - 1 = 4.
+--------------------------------------------------------------+
| So, there are  = 10 geometrically |
| different pairs of diagonals emanating from each vertex. |
+-------------------------------=========----------------------+
Hence, in total, there are 8*10 = 80 geometrically different pairs of diagonals
emanating from 8 vertices of the octagon.
Each pair can be colored in 2 different ways, red-blue or blue-red.
It gives 2*80 = 160 different ways to color all the pairs of diagonals,
emanated from 8 vertices of the octagon.
ANSWER. There are 160 different ways to color all the pairs of diagonals,
emanated from 8 vertices of the octagon.
Solved.
------------------------------
In my solution, I assume that the question does relate to all possible pairs
of diagonals for  vertices of the octagon, having a common endpoint at vertices.
I make this addition, since the question in the post is posed in a very unclear way.
If you want the answer for one single vertex, then the number of geometrically different pairs
of diagonals from this vertex is 10 and the number of different coloring of these 10 pairs is 20.
In the post by @CPhill, counting of diagonals in the octagon is made INCORRECTLY.
|
|
|
