SOLUTION: If m is a positive integer and sqrt(4m^2+29) is an integer, then what is m?

Algebra ->  Numeric Fractions Calculators, Lesson and Practice -> SOLUTION: If m is a positive integer and sqrt(4m^2+29) is an integer, then what is m?      Log On


   



Question 1209939: If m is a positive integer and sqrt(4m^2+29) is an integer, then what is m?
Found 4 solutions by math_tutor2020, ikleyn, mccravyedwin, AnlytcPhil:
Answer by math_tutor2020(3816) About Me  (Show Source):
You can put this solution on YOUR website!

Answer: m = 7

Work Shown
k = some integer
k = sqrt(4m^2+29)
k^2 = 4m^2+29
k^2-4m^2 = 29
(k-2m)(k+2m) = 29
29 is prime so the only factors are 1 and 29.

k and m are integers, so k-2m and k+2m are also integers.
In order for (k-2m)(k+2m) = 29 to be the case, we'd need either
system%28k-2m+=+1%2Ck%2B2m=29%29
or
system%28k-2m+=+29%2Ck%2B2m=1%29
In either system of equations, adding straight down leads to 2k = 30 which solves to k = 15.

Then,
k-2m = 1
15-2m = 1
-2m = 1-15
-2m = -14
m = -14/(-2)
m = 7
Or,
k-2m = 29
15-2m = 29
-2m = 29-15
-2m = 14
m = 14/(-2)
m = -7
We ignore m = -7 since your teacher stated that m > 0
Check: sqrt(4m^2+29)=sqrt(4*7^2+29)=15 is an integer.

Answer by ikleyn(52777) About Me  (Show Source):
You can put this solution on YOUR website!
.
If m is a positive integer and sqrt(4m^2+29) is an integer, then what is m?
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

If   sqrt%284m%5E2%2B29%29  is an integer number n, then

    4m^2 + 29 = n^2

    29 = n^2 - 4m^2

    29 = (n-2m)*(n+2m).


29 is a prime number, so it has two possible decompositions into the product of prime factors 

        29 = 1* 29   or  29 = (-1)*(-29).


Therefore, we have 4 systems of linear equations to analyze

    n - 2m =  1,    (1)
    n + 2m = 29,    (2)

    n - 2m =  -1,   (3)
    n + 2m = -29,   (4)

    n - 2m =  29,   (5)
    n + 2m =   1,   (6)

    n - 2m = -29,   (7)
    n + 2m =  -1.   (8)



From system (1), (2), by subtracting equations, we have 

    2m - (-2m) = 29-1,  4m = 28,  m = 28/4 = 7  and then  n = 1 + 2m = 1 + 2*7 = 15.

So, the solution pair is (m,n) = (7,15), and it works properly: 

    sqrt%284%2A7%5E2%2B29%29 = sqrt%284%2A49%2B29%29 = sqrt%28225%29 = 15.



From system (3), (4), by subtracting equations, we have 

    2m - (-2m) = -29-(-1),  4m = -28,  m = -28/4 = -7.  

It does not work, since the number m should be positive, by the condition.



From system (5), (6), by subtracting equations, we have 

    2m - (-2m) = 1-29,  4m = -28,  m = -28/4 = -7.  

It does not work, since the number m should be positive, by the condition.



From system (7), (8), by subtracting equations, we have 

    2m - (-2m) = -1 - (-29),  4m = 28,  m = 28/4 = 7  and then  n = 1 + 2m = 1 + 2*7 = 15.

So, the solution pair is (m,n) = (7,15), the same as we got from system (1), (2), 
and it works properly:  sqrt%284%2A7%5E2%2B29%29 = sqrt%284%2A49%2B29%29 = sqrt%28225%29 = 15.


ANSWER.  For the given problem, there is a unique solution for m.  It is m = 7.

Solved.

I placed this my solution here after the solution by tutor @math_tutor2020 to make the analysis complete.


///////////////////////////


My comment/response to the Edwin's comment, regarding my post.

    For this given problem, considering all four decompositions

        29 = 1*29 = 29*1 = (-1)*(-29) = (-29)*(-1)


    is NECESSARY for the completeness of the analysis.


    So, all 4 (four) cases/decompositions MUST be considered, exactly as it was made in my post.



Answer by mccravyedwin(406) About Me  (Show Source):
You can put this solution on YOUR website!
Tutor Ikleyn states

29 is a prime number, so it has two possible decompositions in the product of
prime numbers 

        29 = 1* 29   or  29 = (-1)*(-29).

But unless we are in modern algebra where there are such things as "groups",
"rings", etc., and where "prime number" has a different definition, then "prime
number" always means a positive integer with exactly 2 unique positive integer
factors.

While 29 = (-1)*(-29) is true, it is not a decomposition in the product of prime
numbers.

Edwin

Answer by AnlytcPhil(1806) About Me  (Show Source):
You can put this solution on YOUR website!
Tutor Ikleyn states

29 is a prime number, so it has two possible decompositions in the product of
prime numbers 

        29 = 1* 29   or  29 = (-1)*(-29).

You may not say that. You may say:

29 is a prime number, so it has ONE possible decomposition in the product of
prime numbers 

        29 = 1* 29.

Or you may say:

29 is a prime number, so it has two possible decompositions in the product of
integers. 

        29 = 1* 29   or  29 = (-1)*(-29).


Edwin