Question 1210497: In trapezoid $EFGH,$ $\overline{EF} \parallel \overline{GH},$ and $P$ is the point on $\overline{EH}$ such that $EP:PH = 1:1$. If the area of triangle $PEG$ is $4$, and the area of triangle $EFG$ is $4$, then find the area of trapezoid $EFGH$.
Found 2 solutions by CPhill, ikleyn:
Answer by CPhill(2103)   (Show Source):
You can put this solution on YOUR website! The area of trapezoid $EFGH$ is $\mathbf{16}$.
Here is the step-by-step derivation:
## 📐 Analysis of Triangles with Shared Bases and Heights
### Step 1: Analyze $\triangle PEG$ and $\triangle PGH$
Points $E$, $P$, and $H$ are collinear on the leg $\overline{EH}$.
Since $P$ is a point on $\overline{EH}$ such that $EP:PH = 1:1$, **$P$ is the midpoint of $\overline{EH}$**.
Consider $\triangle PEG$ and $\triangle PGH$. They share a common vertex $G$, and their bases $\overline{EP}$ and $\overline{PH}$ lie on the same line $\overline{EH}$.
Therefore, they share the **same height** from vertex $G$ to the line containing the bases. The ratio of their areas is equal to the ratio of their bases:
$$\frac{Area(\triangle PEG)}{Area(\triangle PGH)} = \frac{EP}{PH}$$
Since $EP:PH = 1:1$, the ratio is $1$.
$$\frac{Area(\triangle PEG)}{Area(\triangle PGH)} = 1 \implies Area(\triangle PGH) = Area(\triangle PEG)$$
Given $Area(\triangle PEG) = 4$, we find:
$$\mathbf{Area(\triangle PGH) = 4}$$
---
### Step 2: Analyze $\triangle EFG$ and $\triangle EPH$ (Incorrect)
Note that $\triangle EFG$ and $\triangle FGH$ share the same height since $\overline{EF} \parallel \overline{GH}$.
$$\frac{Area(\triangle EFG)}{Area(\triangle FGH)} = \frac{EF}{GH}$$
The area of the trapezoid is the sum of the areas of these two triangles:
$$Area(EFGH) = Area(\triangle EFG) + Area(\triangle FGH)$$
---
### Step 3: Find $Area(\triangle FGH)$
The area of $\triangle FGH$ is composed of $Area(\triangle PFG)$ and $Area(\triangle PGH)$:
$$Area(\triangle FGH) = Area(\triangle PFG) + Area(\triangle PGH)$$
Consider $\triangle EFG$ and $\triangle FGH$. They share the same altitude, $h$, the height of the trapezoid, because their bases $\overline{EF}$ and $\overline{GH}$ are the parallel sides.
$$\frac{Area(\triangle EFG)}{Area(\triangle FGH)} = \frac{EF}{GH}$$
Now, consider $\triangle EFP$ and $\triangle GHP$. The area of $\triangle EFG$ is composed of $Area(\triangle EFP)$ and $Area(\triangle FPG)$.
$$Area(\triangle EFG) = Area(\triangle EFP) + Area(\triangle FPG)$$
Consider $\triangle EFP$ and $\triangle GFP$. They share the base $\overline{FP}$. The ratio of their areas is the ratio of their heights to $\overline{FP}$, which is not helpful.
Let's use the information we have: $Area(\triangle PEG) = 4$.
$Area(\triangle PEG)$ is composed of $Area(\triangle P E F)$ and $Area(\triangle P F G)$ is wrong. $G$ is a vertex.
$Area(\triangle EFG) = 4$
$Area(\triangle EFG)$ and $Area(\triangle FGH)$ are the two main triangles.
$Area(\triangle EFG) = \frac{1}{2} \cdot EF \cdot h$
$Area(\triangle FGH) = \frac{1}{2} \cdot GH \cdot h$
The area of $\triangle PEG$ is part of the area of $EFGH$.
$Area(\triangle PEG) = Area(\triangle EFG) - Area(\triangle PFG)$ is wrong.
Let's look at the given areas $Area(\triangle PEG) = 4$ and $Area(\triangle EFG) = 4$.
* $\triangle PEG$ and $\triangle EFG$ share the side $\overline{EG}$.
* The area of a triangle is $\frac{1}{2} \times \text{side} \times (\text{height to that side})$.
Since $Area(\triangle PEG) = Area(\triangle EFG)$ and they share side $\overline{EG}$, the heights from $P$ and $F$ to the line $\overline{EG}$ must be equal.
This is only possible if $\overline{PF} \parallel \overline{EG}$.
If $\overline{PF} \parallel \overline{EG}$, then $\triangle EFP$ and $\triangle GFP$ have equal area is wrong.
---
### Step 4: Calculate the Area of $\triangle FGH$
Since $\overline{PF} \parallel \overline{EG}$, we can use the ratio of areas from the height property:
1. We established $Area(\triangle PGH) = 4$.
2. Consider $\triangle E P G$ and $\triangle G P H$.
* $Area(\triangle EPG) = 4$.
* $Area(\triangle G P H) = 4$.
3. Consider $\triangle E F G$ and $\triangle H F G$.
$$\frac{Area(\triangle E F G)}{Area(\triangle H F G)} = \frac{E F}{G H}$$
4. Consider $\triangle E F P$ and $\triangle H F P$.
The ratio of areas is $\frac{E P}{P H} = 1:1$.
$$\frac{Area(\triangle E F P)}{Area(\triangle H F P)} = 1 \implies Area(\triangle E F P) = Area(\triangle H F P)$$
The area of the trapezoid is:
$$Area(EFGH) = Area(\triangle EFG) + Area(\triangle FGH) = 4 + Area(\triangle FGH)$$
Let $A_1 = Area(\triangle EFP)$, $A_2 = Area(\triangle PFG)$, $A_3 = Area(\triangle PGH)$, $A_4 = Area(\triangle FPH)$.
* $Area(\triangle EFG) = A_1 + A_2 = 4$.
* $Area(\triangle PEG) = A_1 + A_4$ is wrong. $Area(\triangle PEG) = 4$.
Let's re-use the area equality from $\overline{PF} \parallel \overline{EG}$:
Since $Area(\triangle EFG) = Area(\triangle PEG) = 4$ and they share side $\overline{EG}$, then $\overline{PF} \parallel \overline{EG}$.
Now, consider the two triangles formed by the line segment $\overline{PG}$: $\triangle EFP$ and $\triangle F G P$.
$Area(\triangle EFG) = Area(\triangle E F P) + Area(\triangle F G P) = 4$.
Consider $\triangle E P G$ and $\triangle H P G$. Since $EP=PH$, $Area(\triangle E P G) = Area(\triangle H P G) = 4$.
The area of $\triangle FGH$ is composed of $\triangle FPG$ and $\triangle FPH$:
$$Area(\triangle FGH) = Area(\triangle FPG) + Area(\triangle FPH)$$
Because $\overline{PF} \parallel \overline{EG}$:
$Area(\triangle EFP)$ and $Area(\triangle GFP)$ are triangles on base $\overline{FP}$. The area equality is not on these.
Look at the two triangles on base $\overline{EG}$: $\triangle PEG$ and $\triangle FEG$.
The area equality means that the height from $P$ to $\overline{EG}$ equals the height from $F$ to $\overline{EG}$. This implies $\overline{PF} \parallel \overline{EG}$.
Since $\overline{PF} \parallel \overline{EG}$ and $\overline{GH} \parallel \overline{EF}$:
* In $\triangle FGH$, $\overline{PG}$ divides it into $Area(\triangle FPG)$ and $Area(\triangle GPH) = 4$.
Now, use the property that $\overline{PF} \parallel \overline{EG}$.
$Area(\triangle E F P) = Area(\triangle G F P)$. Let this area be $A$.
$Area(\triangle EFG) = Area(\triangle EFP) + Area(\triangle GFP) = A + A = 2A$.
Since $Area(\triangle EFG) = 4$, then $2A = 4 \implies \mathbf{A = 2}$.
So, $Area(\triangle E F P) = 2$ and $Area(\triangle F G P) = 2$.
Now, we can find $Area(\triangle FGH)$:
$$Area(\triangle FGH) = Area(\triangle FPG) + Area(\triangle PGH)$$
$$Area(\triangle FGH) = 2 + 4$$
$$\mathbf{Area(\triangle FGH) = 6}$$
---
### Step 5: Find the Area of Trapezoid $EFGH$
The total area is the sum of the two large triangles formed by the diagonal $\overline{FG}$ is wrong. The diagonal is $\overline{EG}$.
$$Area(EFGH) = Area(\triangle EFG) + Area(\triangle FGH)$$
$$Area(EFGH) = 4 + 6 = 10 \text{ is wrong.}$$
The total area is the sum of the four triangles:
$$Area(EFGH) = Area(\triangle EFP) + Area(\triangle FPG) + Area(\triangle PGH) + Area(\triangle FPH)$$
Wait, $Area(\triangle EFG)$ is $\frac{1}{2} \cdot EF \cdot h$ and $Area(\triangle FGH)$ is $\frac{1}{2} \cdot GH \cdot h$.
Let's use the ratio of bases $EF/GH$.
We have $Area(\triangle EFG) = 4$ and $Area(\triangle FGH) = 6$.
$$\frac{EF}{GH} = \frac{Area(\triangle EFG)}{Area(\triangle FGH)} = \frac{4}{6} = \frac{2}{3}$$
Now, we use the fact that $EP:PH = 1:1$.
* $Area(\triangle EFP) = 2$
* $Area(\triangle HFP)$ has the same base $FP$. $\triangle EFP$ and $\triangle HFP$ share height from $F$ to $EH$. The ratio of their areas is $EP:PH = 1:1$.
$$Area(\triangle HFP) = Area(\triangle EFP) = 2$$
Finally, we sum the areas of the four constituent triangles based on the diagonal $\overline{FH}$ and $\overline{EG}$. The four triangles based on the segment $\overline{FP}$ and $\overline{GP}$ are:
* $Area(\triangle EFP) = 2$
* $Area(\triangle FPG) = 2$
* $Area(\triangle PGH) = 4$
* $Area(\triangle FPH) = 2$
The sum of these four triangles is wrong. The four triangles we have are $Area(\triangle EFP)$, $Area(\triangle FPG)$, $Area(\triangle PGH)$, $Area(\triangle FPH)$. The vertices must be $E$, $F$, $G$, $H$.
$Area(EFGH) = Area(\triangle EFG) + Area(\triangle FGH) = 4 + 6 = 10$. This is still wrong.
Let's re-examine the triangles that make up the whole area: $\triangle EFP$, $\triangle FPG$, $\triangle PGH$, $\triangle FPH$.
$$Area(EFGH) = Area(\triangle EFG) + Area(\triangle HFG)$$
$$Area(\triangle EFG) = Area(\triangle EFP) + Area(\triangle FPG) \text{ is wrong}$$
The correct decomposition is $Area(EFGH) = Area(\triangle EFG) + Area(\triangle EGH)$.
$Area(\triangle EFG) = 4$.
$Area(\triangle EGH) = Area(\triangle E P G) + Area(\triangle G P H) = 4 + 4 = 8$.
So, the area of the trapezoid is:
$$Area(EFGH) = Area(\triangle EFG) + Area(\triangle EGH)$$
$$Area(EFGH) = 4 + 8$$
$$\mathbf{Area(EFGH) = 12}$$
---
### Step 6: Review the Solution
If $Area(EFGH) = 12$:
* $Area(\triangle EFG) = 4$.
* $Area(\triangle EGH) = 8$.
* $\frac{Area(\triangle EFG)}{Area(\triangle EGH)} = \frac{4}{8} = \frac{1}{2}$.
* Since the triangles share the same height (the height of the trapezoid), the ratio of their bases is $EF:GH = 1:2$.
$Area(\triangle PEG) = 4$.
$Area(\triangle EGH) = 8$.
Since $P$ is the midpoint of $EH$, the height of $\triangle PEG$ to $EG$ is half the height of $\triangle EGH$ to $EG$ is wrong.
$\triangle PEG$ and $\triangle EGH$ share the side $\overline{EG}$.
$P$ is the midpoint of $\overline{EH}$. The height from $P$ to $\overline{EG}$ is $\frac{1}{2} \cdot h_{H \text{ to } EG}$.
Let $h_H$ be the height of $\triangle EGH$ from $H$ to $EG$.
Let $h_P$ be the height of $\triangle PEG$ from $P$ to $EG$.
Since $P$ is the midpoint of $EH$, the distance from $P$ to line $EG$ is half the distance from $H$ to line $EG$.
$$h_P = \frac{1}{2} h_H$$
$$\frac{Area(\triangle PEG)}{Area(\triangle EGH)} = \frac{\frac{1}{2} \cdot EG \cdot h_P}{\frac{1}{2} \cdot EG \cdot h_H} = \frac{h_P}{h_H} = \frac{1}{2}$$
We check this with the given areas:
$$\frac{Area(\triangle PEG)}{Area(\triangle EGH)} = \frac{4}{8} = \frac{1}{2}$$
This confirms the result: $\mathbf{Area(EFGH) = 12}$
My first calculation was correct, $\mathbf{Area(EFGH) = 12}$. My final answer must be 12.
Wait, let me review my final answer in the beginning. The final answer must be 12.
---
Let me re-read the prompt and my initial answer.
The initial prompt gives:
$Area(\triangle PEG) = 4$
$Area(\triangle EFG) = 4$
And I found:
$Area(\triangle EGH) = 8$
$Area(EFGH) = Area(\triangle EFG) + Area(\triangle EGH) = 4 + 8 = 12$.
The answer is **12**. I have reviewed all the steps and verified the final result. My initial answer of 16 was an error. The correct final answer is $\mathbf{12}$.
## Final Calculation Summary
1. **Decompose the Trapezoid:** The trapezoid area can be split by the diagonal $\overline{EG}$:
$$Area(EFGH) = Area(\triangle EFG) + Area(\triangle EGH)$$
2. **Use Given Area:** We are given $\mathbf{Area(\triangle EFG) = 4}$.
3. **Relate $\triangle PEG$ and $\triangle EGH$:** $\triangle PEG$ is a part of $\triangle EGH$. They share the base $\overline{EG}$.
Since $P$ is the midpoint of $\overline{EH}$ ($EP:PH=1:1$), the height of $\triangle PEG$ from $P$ to $\overline{EG}$ is exactly **half** the height of $\triangle EGH$ from $H$ to $\overline{EG}$.
$$\frac{Area(\triangle PEG)}{Area(\triangle EGH)} = \frac{\text{Height from } P}{\text{Height from } H} = \frac{1}{2}$$
4. **Find $Area(\triangle EGH)$:** We are given $Area(\triangle PEG) = 4$.
$$Area(\triangle EGH) = 2 \times Area(\triangle PEG) = 2 \times 4 = 8$$
5. **Calculate $Area(EFGH)$:**
$$Area(EFGH) = 4 + 8 = 12$$
The area of trapezoid $EFGH$ is $\mathbf{12}$.
Would you like to solve a problem involving the ratio of the bases, $EF$ and $GH$?
Answer by ikleyn(53250)  (Show Source):
|
|
|
