|
Question 971804: I had an exam which i failed because of logical questions of this sort.
- What is the equivalent of " A dolphin cannot fly and a bird can swim" is false?
I know this is a question which it involves conjunction but i do not know how to process such in order to arrive with an answer.
Do i have to double negate it?
Please help me. Thanks
Answer by Edwin McCravy(20054) (Show Source):
You can put this solution on YOUR website!
"A dolphin cannot fly and a bird can swim" is false.
Let variables P and Q stand for the 'positive' idea of verbs:
(That is, we use 'can fly' rather than 'cannot fly'):
Let P = "A dolphin can fly."
Let Q = "A bird can swim.
Then only the first part in quotation marks, that is,
"A dolphin cannot fly and a bird can swim"
(without "is false") in symbols is
~P & Q
Then annexing of "is false" means that we are negating that and we must put
parentheses around it and a ~ (negation symbol) before it.
~(~P & Q)
Demorgan's law says this is equivalent to
~~P v ~Q
The double negation before P makes it
P v ~Q
A dolphin can fly or a bird cannot swim.
That is one possible solution.
However there is another equivalent statement we could get.
By commutation we get:
~Q v P
which in words is:
"A bird cannot swim or a dolphin can fly
Then we can use 'material implication' to get
Q -> P
which means
If Q then P
which in words is
If a bird can swim, then a dolphin can fly.
That is another possible solution.
[All statements above which are in red are equivalent to the given statement.]
Edwin
|
|
|
| |