|
Question 351994: Determine which of the following three statements are equivalent.
(a) not r or ( not q and not r)
(b) not r or (not p and not q)
(c) not[ r or ( p and q) ]
Answer by Edwin McCravy(20054) (Show Source):
You can put this solution on YOUR website! (a) not r or ( not q and not r)
(b) not r or (not p and not q)
(c) not[ r or ( p and q) ]
Notation ~ means "not", \/ means "or", /\ means "and"
Rules: ~ means to change whatever follows it to F if it is T
and to T if it is F
/\ is F unless it has T on both sides of it; then it's T
\/ is T unless it has F on both sides of it; then it's F
Make truth tables for all three following the above rules:
Truth table for the first one:
(a) not r or ( not q and not r)
Note: p does not appear in this one and hence a
4-line truth table would do, but we will put in
a column for p anyway so we can easily compare the final
result with the results of the other two.
p|q|r|~q|~r|~q/\~r|~r\/(~q/\~r)
T|T|T| F| F| F | F
T|T|F| F| T| F | T
T|F|T| T| F| F | F
T|F|F| T| T| T | T
F|T|T| F| F| F | F
F|T|F| F| T| F | T
F|F|T| T| F| F | F
F|F|F| T| T| T | T
(b) not r or (not p and not q)
p|q|r|~p|~q|~r|~p/\~q|~r\/(~p/\~q)
T|T|T| F| F| F| F | F
T|T|F| F| F| T| F | T
T|F|T| F| T| F| F | F
T|F|F| F| T| T| F | T
F|T|T| T| F| F| F | F
F|T|F| T| F| T| F | T
F|F|T| T| T| F| T | T
F|F|F| T| T| T| T | T
(c) not[ r or ( p and q) ]
p|q|r|p/\q|r\/(p/\q)|~[r\/(p/\q)]
T|T|T| T | T | F
T|T|F| T | T | F
T|F|T| F | T | F
T|F|F| F | F | T
F|T|T| F | T | F
F|T|F| F | F | T
F|F|T| F | T | F
F|F|F| F | F | T
None of the three have the exact same truth table, so
none of them are equivalent.
Edwin
|
|
|
| |