1. ~~G 2. (P * Y) v (X -> ~W) 3. (P * Y) -> ~G 4. ~W -> ~G /~X ----------------------------------- 5. ~~W 4,1 Modus Tollens 6. ~(P * Y) 2,1 Modus Tollens 7. X -> ~W 2,6 Disjunctive Syllogism 8. ~X 7,5 Modus Tollens