SOLUTION: A shoemaker died, leaving behind 17 pairs of men's shoes and boots. In his last will and testament he disposed of them as follows: 1/2 of the collection to his youngest, hardworki

Algebra ->  Customizable Word Problem Solvers  -> Misc -> SOLUTION: A shoemaker died, leaving behind 17 pairs of men's shoes and boots. In his last will and testament he disposed of them as follows: 1/2 of the collection to his youngest, hardworki      Log On

Ad: Over 600 Algebra Word Problems at edhelper.com


   



Question 29713: A shoemaker died, leaving behind 17 pairs of men's shoes and boots. In his last will and testament he disposed of them as follows: 1/2 of the collection to his youngest, hardworking, son; 1/3 to the middle son; and 1/9 to "Lazybones", the eldest son.
Understanding that it was not possible to divide the 17 pairs into halves, thirds, and ninths, the exasperated executor of the will tossed in his own footwear, making it a total of eighteen pairs, which he divided as follows: 1/2, or 9 pairs, to the youngest son; 1/3, or 6 pairs, to the middle son; and 1/9, or 2 pairs, to the eldest son.
Upon realizing that adding up 9, 6, and 2 made 17, the executor elatedly retrieved his own pair of shoes and closed the estate.
Question: What's the mistake in the shoemaker's problem?

Found 2 solutions by jb007mi6, longjonsilver:
Answer by jb007mi6(53) About Me  (Show Source):
You can put this solution on YOUR website!
...not sure there is one...i went over it several times...can't get anything

Answer by longjonsilver(2297) About Me  (Show Source):
You can put this solution on YOUR website!
1/2 and 1/3 and 1/9 add up to 17/18 and not to 18/18, so you will get a discrepancy when you try to divide the shoes up.

Jon.