50.0 centimeters means that the side was rounded to the nearest tenth of a centimeter. Therefore the side could have been as long as 50.04999999999 cm or as short as 49.95 centimeters. Either way, rounded to tenths it would have been 50.0 centimeters. It is only necessary to calculate the percentage error when the error was due to rounding up. But let's see why that is the case. In the first case the error would have been 50.04999999999-50.0 = 0.04999999999 and the fraction error would have been 0.04999999999/50.04999999999 and the decimal error would be 0.0009999001 and the percent error would be 0.0999999% In the second case, the error would have been 50.0-49.95 = 0.05 centimeters, and the fraction error would have been 0.05/49.95 and the decimal error would be 0.001001... and the percent error would be 0.1001001...%, or 0.1% So you see, it is only necessary to calculate the percentage error when the error was due to rounding up. That's because the percentage error is slightly more when the error is due to rounding up than when it is due to rounding down, and we want the maximum possible percentage error. Edwin