The other tutor's solution is wrong for if the hiker had gonemph, then in 3 hours he would have gone 8 miles and the biker would have gone 24 miles and they would be 16 miles apart, not 24 miles apart. Here's the correct solution: Let r = the rate of the hiker Then 3r = the rate of the biker Then after 3 hours, using d=rt, the hiker went r*(3) or 3r miles And after the same 3 hours, the biker went (3r)*(3) or 9r miles. Then 9r is 24 more than 3r 9r = 3r + 24 6r = 24 r = 4 mi/hr To analyze the problem further as a check, the biker went 3 times as fast or 12 mi/hr and after 3 hours the biker had gone 36 miles and the hiker had gone 4*3 or 12 miles, and they were therefore 36-12 or 24 miles apart after 3 hours. Edwin