Suppose they are a,b,c,d,e, where. Since five is an odd number of numbers, the middle one, c, must be 11. Since their average is 9, And since c=11 Since the mode is 11, there must be more than one 11 among them, so either b=11 or d=11 or both. If b=11, , If d=11, , We wonder if a can be 0, the smallest whole number. If so or , which means or So d=11, e=12, or b=11, e=12 So the numbers can be a=0, b=11, c=11, d=11, e=12 and so the smallest whole number "a" can be is 0. Edwin