SOLUTION: I have 5 more brothers than sisters, and each of my brothers have 3 more brothers than sisters. (If there are 10 family members total, how many are brothers)

Algebra.Com
Question 1204311: I have 5 more brothers than sisters, and each of my brothers have 3 more brothers than sisters. (If there are 10 family members total, how many are brothers)

Found 2 solutions by ikleyn, MathTherapy:
Answer by ikleyn(52855)   (Show Source): You can put this solution on YOUR website!
.

At this forum, there is a nice solution to similar problem, produced years before by our tutors

https://www.algebra.com/algebra/homework/playground/test.faq.question.991197.html


Especially, the solution by the tutor ankor@dixie-net.com has a nice (= a beautiful) idea

on how to start the solution, so you have everything to follow this pattern.


I myself will not write the solution, since the part of the condition
"there are 10 family members total" is ambiguous and admits different interpretations
(including mother, father, grandmother, grandfather etc.). I do not like when
illiterate problems composers turn their problems to soup of words.



Answer by MathTherapy(10555)   (Show Source): You can put this solution on YOUR website!
I have 5 more brothers than sisters, and each of my brothers have 3 more brothers than sisters. (If there are 10 family members total, how many are brothers)

I do believe that this problem should be edited to read: I have 5 more brothers than sisters, and each of my brothers
have 3 more brothers than sisters. (If there are 10 family members siblings total, how many are  brothers) MALES)

Let the number of brothers be B
Then number of sisters = B - 5
Including the NARRATOR, we get the following TOTAL-SIBLINGS equation: 1 + B + B - 5 = 10
                                                                             2B - 4 = 10
                                                                                 2B = 14
                                                          Number of brothers, or 
SCENARIO #1 (MALE NARRATOR)
Now, if a MALE narrator, the number of MALE SIBLINGS = 7 + 1 = 8. This gives us a total of 8 brothers
and 2 sisters, which means that each brother would have 7 brothers and 2 sisters, or 5 more brothers
than sisters. This makes the statement: "each of my brothers have 3 more brothers than sisters," FALSE.  

SCENARIO #2 (FEMALE NARRATOR)
Now, if the NARRATOR were FEMALE, and with the established number of brothers being 7 (see above), the number of
FEMALE SIBLINGS would be 3 (2 + narrator). This gives us a total of 7 brothers and 3 sisters, which means that the
narrator (one of the sisters) has 7 brothers and 2 sisters, or 5 more brothers that sisters. This makes the statement:
"I have 5 more brothers than sisters," TRUE. 

This also means that each brother would have 6 brothers and 3 sisters, or 3 more brothers than sisters, which also 
makes the statement: "each of my brothers have 3 more brothers than sisters," a TRUE one.

Hence, the NARRATOR is FEMALE, and there are 3 FEMALE and 7 MALE SIBLINGS!

RELATED QUESTIONS

I have five more brothers than sisters, and each of my brothers also has five more... (answered by solver91311,ankor@dixie-net.com)
I have five more brothers than sisters, and each of my brothers also has 5 more brothers... (answered by ankor@dixie-net.com)
I have 5 more brothers than sisters, and each of my brothers also has five more brothers... (answered by ikleyn)
I have two more sisters than brothers. Each of my sisters has two more sisters than... (answered by ikleyn)
If I have 2 more sisters then brothers and each of my sisters also has 2 more sisters... (answered by Shin123,ikleyn,Edwin McCravy)
I have two more sisters than brothers.Each of my sisters has two more sisters than... (answered by ikleyn)
Hi, So my friends have been going crazy over a problem. I'm not sure of the exact... (answered by MathLover1)
Hi, I just posted this problem but judging by Ms.MathLover's response, I have confused... (answered by ikleyn,MathLover1)
My daughter has many sisters. She has as many sisters as she has brothers. Each of her... (answered by ankor@dixie-net.com)