I'd rather reason something out all by myself when possible, rather than go looking where someone else has already figured it out. That's just me. Being able to reason it out yourself is the main thing, not to know the answer. This student already knew the answer. Trying to do it yourself is the only way to train your brain. When I studied math in school and college, I would cover up the explanation in the book of how to solve each problem, and first try to figure it out all by myself. Then only when I got stuck, would I uncover the explanation. Then I'd only uncover a little at a time. Suppose the back side numbers are A, B and C, like this: Disk Front Back 1 6 A 2 7 B 3 8 C One thing to notice is that there are exactly 2 ways each disk can land, so there are 2∙2∙2=8 ways they can all three land. And there are 8 numbers 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, and 22 numbers they must add to, so there are no "extras", that is, there is only one way to get each of those sums. If the first two disks fall 6 and 7, there must be a 9 on the back of the third disk so that the largest sum, 6+7+9=22, can be made. So C=9. If the first and third disks fall 6 and 8, there must be a 2 on the back of the second disk so that the smallest sum, 6+8+2=16 can be made. So B=2. We can now make these sums: 2+7+8=17, 2+7+9=18, 6+7+8=21, 6+7+9=22 If the second and third disks fall 7 and 8, there must be a 5 on the back of the first disk so that the largest remaining sum 6+5+9=20 can be made. So A=5. Now we must check to see if we can make all the sums: Disk Front Back 1 6 2 2 7 5 3 8 9 2+5+8=15, 2+5+9=16, 2+7+8=17, 2+7+9=18, 6+5+8=19, 6+5+9=20, 6+7+8=21, 6+7+9=22. Ah, sweet success! Edwin