SOLUTION: Alice and Bob play three chess games. Alice is 10 times more likely to win a game than Bob. Find the probability that Alice will win all three games. AND Bob will win all

Algebra.Com
Question 1175734: Alice and Bob play three chess games. Alice is 10 times more likely to win a game than Bob. Find the probability that
Alice will win all three games.
AND
Bob will win all three games.

Found 2 solutions by ikleyn, greenestamps:
Answer by ikleyn(52787)   (Show Source): You can put this solution on YOUR website!
.

The translated, the condition means that


    p(A wins a game) = ;  p(B wins a game) = .


THEREFORE,


(a)  p(Alice wins all 3 games of 3) =  = 0.7513 = 75.13%.


(b)  p(Bob   wins all 3 games of 3) =  = 0.000751 = 0.075%.

Solved.



Answer by greenestamps(13200)   (Show Source): You can put this solution on YOUR website!


The language used in the statement of the problem is poor, leading to different interpretations and different answers.

Tutor @ikleyn interpreted "Alice is 10 times more likely to win a game than Bob" to mean that if Bob's probability is x then Alice's probability is 10 times x, or 10x. That makes their probabilities of winning 1/11 and 10/11.

That is a possible interpretation of the given information.

However, the grammatically correct interpretation of the phrase is that if Bob's probability is x then Alice's probability is x PLUS 10 (more) times x, or x+10x = 11x. That makes their probabilities of winning 1/12 and 11/12.

So my answers to the questions would be

P(Alice wins all 3 games) = (11/12)^3
P(Bob wins all 3 games) = (1/12)^3

Unfortunately, in everyday usage "4 times as much as" and "4 times more than" are carelessly used to mean the same thing. And to further the misfortune, the "4 times more than" phrase is used far more often than the "4 times as much as" phrase; so most of the time the information that is supposed to be getting conveyed is false.

It is very likely that the author of the problem intended the answers to be given as shown by the other tutor. However, if the statement of the problem is interpreted grammatically correctly, the correct answers are those that I show.


RELATED QUESTIONS

What is the probability of each student winning the competition if four students, Mary,... (answered by ikleyn)
A AND B PLAY 12 GAMES OF CHESS,OF WHICH 6 ARE WON BY A,4 BY B AND 2 END IN A TIE.THEY... (answered by stanbon)
Hi A sum of money is split between Bob Ted and Alice in the ratio 6:2:5 respectively.If... (answered by josgarithmetic,greenestamps,ikleyn)
Alice is 8 years older than bob Three years from now Alice will be twice as old as bobs... (answered by erica65404)
Bob is three times older than Alice. Ten years ago Bob's age was twice that what Alice's... (answered by Cromlix)
Suppose that Bob is four years older than Alice. In two years, Bob will be twice... (answered by josmiceli,Alan3354)
Alice and Bob each have a certain amount of money. If Alice receives dollars from Bob,... (answered by ankor@dixie-net.com)
5) Alice is trying to send a message to Bob. Eve is an eavesdropper who randomly corrupts (answered by mathmate)
Goliath and David play a game in which there are no ties. Each player is equally likely... (answered by rothauserc)