(kx+1)² = 8x k²x² + 2kx + 1 = 8x k²x² + 2kx - 8x + 1 = 0 k²x² + (2k-8)x + 1 = 0 Compare to ax² + bx + c = 0 a = k², b = 2k-8, c = 1 For the solutions to have no real roots, the discriminant must be negative, that is, less than zero. Discriminant = b²-4ac = (2k-8)² - 4k²(1) = 4k²-32k+64 - 4k² = -32k+64 -32k+64 < 0 -32k < -64 k > 2 Therefore the smallest positive integer k for which the equation (kx+1)^2=8x has no real roots is 3. [Notice: I changed your word "biggest" to "smallest", for every value of k greater than 2 will cause the equation to have no real roots, even if k were ten million trillion! If the problem had "biggest" there instead of "smallest", then the problem was botched. Point this out to your teacher.] Edwin