SOLUTION: Please help me solve
Bayside Insurance offers two health plans. Under Plan A, Sam would have to pay the first $170 of his medical bills, plus 35% of the rest. Under Plan B, Sam
Algebra.Com
Question 205543: Please help me solve
Bayside Insurance offers two health plans. Under Plan A, Sam would have to pay the first $170 of his medical bills, plus 35% of the rest. Under Plan B, Sam would pay the first $210, but only 30% of the rest. For what amount of medical bills will Plan B save Sam money? Assume he was over $210 in bills. Sam would save with Plan B if he had more than $_____ in bills.
Found 2 solutions by Theo, stanbon:
Answer by Theo(13342) (Show Source): You can put this solution on YOUR website!
problem:
Bayside Insurance offers two health plans. Under Plan A, Sam would have to pay the first $170 of his medical bills, plus 35% of the rest. Under Plan B, Sam would pay the first $210, but only 30% of the rest. For what amount of medical bills will Plan B save Sam money? Assume he was over $210 in bills. Sam would save with Plan B if he had more than $_____ in bills.
-----
let x = cost of sam's medical bills.
-----
Under Plan A, Sam pays 170 + .35 * (x - 170)
Under Plan B, Sam pays $210 + .3 * (x - 210)
-----
Assume x > $210
-----
Break even point is when Plan A costs the same as plan B.
This happens when:
170 + .35*(x-170) = 210 + .3*(x-210)
-----
removing the parentheses, this equation becomes:
170 + .35x - 59.5 = 210 + .3x - 63
simplifying, this becomes:
110.5 + .35x = 147 + .3x
subtracting 110.5 from both sides and subtracting .3x from both sides of the equation gets:
.35x - .3x = 147 - 110.5
simplifying gets:
.05x = 36.5
dividing both sides of the equation by .05 gets:
x = 730
-----
testing by substituting in the break even equation gets:
170 + .35*(730-170) = 210 + .3*(730-210)
removing parentheses gets:
170 + 255.5 - 59.5 = 210 + 219 - 63
simplifying gets:
366 = 366
confirming that the value of x is good.
-----
Answer to your question is:
Sam would save with plan B is Sam had more than $730 in bills.
-----
As a test, assume Sam has $750 in bills.
Under plan A Sam would pay:
170 + .35*(750 - 170) = 170 + .35 * (580) = 170 + $203 = $373
Under plan B Sam would pay:
210 + .3*(750-210) = 210 + .3 * (540) = 210 + 162 = $372
-----
The numbers might be smaller but you could test with as little as a penny over the break even point.
To make it reasonable, we'll use $1.00 over the break even point.
Assume the bills were $731.
Under Plan A Sam would pay $170 + (.35)*($731-$170) = $170 + .35*561 = $366.35
Under Plan B Sam would pay $210 + (.3)*($731-$210) = $210 + .34*521 = $366.30
-----
A graph of both equations would show this.
Below $730 Plan A should be cheaper.
Above $730 Plan B should be cheaper.
-----
-----
when x = 0, plan A intersects the y axis at 110.5
when x = 0, plan B intersect the y axis at 147.00
-----
you can see that plan A is cheaper than plan B up to x = $731 and then becomes more expensive.
-----
You could have worked this directly by making the plan b equation less than the plan a equation rather than equal.
-----
if you did that you would have had:
210 + .3*(x - 210) < 170 + .35*(x - 170)
you solve in the same way but you're dealing with an inequality now and the inequality rules prevail.
first thing is to remove the parentheses.
equation becomes:
210 + .3x - (.3*210) < 170 + .35x - (.35*170)
subtracting 170 from both sides and subtracting .3x from both sides and adding (.35*170) to both sides gets:
210 - 170 - (.3*210) + (.35*170) < .35x - .3x
combining like terms gets:
40 - (.3*210) + (.35*170) < .05x
simplifying further gets:
40 - 63 + 59.5 < .05x
which becomes:
36.5 < .05x
dividing both sides by .05 gets:
36.5/.05 < x
which becomes:
730 < x
-----
730 < x is the same as x > 730 so the result of this equation is x > 730.
when x is greater than 730 plan b is cheaper.
-----
this is the same result we got earlier so it confirms the results and was more direct because the inequality equation rather than the break even equation was used.
-----
Answer by stanbon(75887) (Show Source): You can put this solution on YOUR website!
Bayside Insurance offers two health plans.
Under Plan A, Sam would have to pay the first $170 of his medical bills, plus 35% of the rest.
Under Plan B, Sam would pay the first $210, but only 30% of the rest.
-----------------------
For what amount of medical bills will Plan B save Sam money?
Let the medical bills be "x" dollars:
Plan A cost: 170+ 0.35(x-170)
Plan B cost: 210+ 0.30(x-210)
---
Inequality:
Plan B < Plan A
210 + 0.30(x-210) < 170 + 0.35(x-170)
0.70*210 + 0.30x < 0.65*170 + 0.35x
0.05x > 36.6
x > $730
----------------------------------------------------
Assume he was over $210 in bills. Sam would save with Plan B if he had more than $_730.00____ in bills.
============================================
Cheers,
Stan H.
RELATED QUESTIONS
Could someone help me with this problem? I am confused?
Bayside Insurance offers... (answered by ankor@dixie-net.com,Fombitz)
Please Help!!!!Could someone help me with this problem? I am confused?
Bayside... (answered by Theo)
Could someone please show me how to solve this problem? Bayside insurance offers two... (answered by jorel1380)
Bayside Insurance offers two health plans. Under plan A, Giselle would have to pay the... (answered by solver91311,alanc)
Bayside insurance offers two health plans. Under plan a, Giselle would have to pay the... (answered by mananth)
Bayside Insurance offers two health plans. Under plan A, Giselle would have to pay the... (answered by stanbon,solver91311)
Bayside Insurance offers two health plans. Under plan A, Giselle would have to pay the... (answered by solver91311)
Bayside insurance offers two health plans. Under plan A, Giselle would have to pay the... (answered by mananth)
Bayside insurance offers two health plans. Under plan A, Giselle would have to pay the... (answered by ankor@dixie-net.com)