SOLUTION: 5/X = X/20 Do I use the positive solution, the negative solution, or both?

Question 236940: 5/X = X/20
Do I use the positive solution, the negative solution, or both?
Found 2 solutions by checkley77, solver91311:
Answer by checkley77(12844) (Show Source): You can put this solution on YOUR website!
5/X = X/20
X^2=100
X=SQRT100
X=+/-10 ANS.
BOTH = & - ANSWERS ARE VALID.
Answer by solver91311(24713) (Show Source): You can put this solution on YOUR website!

Well, since:

and

From a purely mathematical point of view, either solution makes the original equation a true statement, and therefore both solutions are members of the solution set.

On the other hand, if you are using a proportion to solve a physical problem where the answer is a positive measure of something, then you would certainly exclude the negative root. On the other hand, you might have a problem that requires you to find a root that is less than zero -- hence you would exclude the positive root.

So, you tell me.

John

RELATED QUESTIONS
What is the expression for the solution in this interval notation? 5-x is is < or = to 0 (answered by jim_thompson5910)
Do you solve the equation inside the absolute value first and then make the number... (answered by edjones)
Question 1044755: Question 1044751: hello, why does |2x-3| + 4 =2 have no solution. (answered by Boreal)
What is the solution set of the absolute value sentence |x - 6| = -10? A. {4/3, -4} (answered by robertb)
Use Descartes rule of signs to determine how many positive and how many negative real... (answered by mukhopadhyay)
I have some mixture problems i need help with. Can you please help me? I have to use... (answered by ankor@dixie-net.com)
I want to find out how to solve this question: "How many liters of a 10% solution of... (answered by Alan3354)
could you please help me solve this equation |x+1| >(or equal) 4 I tried using... (answered by josgarithmetic,ikleyn)
Hi i'm trying to work on my assignments again.I'm trying to find out if I did the right... (answered by stanbon)