Bobby's number adds one each time, and Dawn's number subtracts 1 each time. Therefore the sum of the numbers they are speaking is always the same. Since the sum of their numbers is 47+83 = 130 at one particular time, the sum of the numbers they are saying is ALWAYS 130. [To illustrate, when Bobby says 48, Dawn will say 82, and 48+82=130. And when Bobby said 46, Dawn said 84 and 46+84=130] Therefore when Bobby said 1, Dawn had to say 129, because 1+129 = 130. Edwin