SOLUTION: A student says that a + b = a because the variable b cancels. How do you respond? c + b c

Algebra.Com
Question 174298: A student says that a + b = a because the variable b cancels. How do you respond?
c + b c

Answer by stanbon(75887)   (Show Source): You can put this solution on YOUR website!
A student says that a + b = a because the variable b cancels. How do you respond?
c + b c
----------------------------------------------
[(a+b])/(c+b) = (a/c)
----
I say the student is wrong because you cannot cancel terms, only factors
that are common to numerator and denominator.
==================
Cheers,
Stan H.

RELATED QUESTIONS

9) A student claims that a – b – c is the same as a – ( b – c ). How do you respond? (answered by jim_thompson5910,solver91311)
10) A student says that the square root of 25 equal –5. How do you... (answered by jim_thompson5910)
A student says that the square root of 25 equals –5. How do you... (answered by stanbon)
7) A student says that A = {1, {1}} has only one element. How do you... (answered by Fombitz)
7) A student says that A = {1, {1}} has only one element. How do you... (answered by solver91311)
A student says that repeating decimals can not be multiplied together. How do you... (answered by stanbon)
6) A student says that 3 divided by 0 is 0. How do you... (answered by jim_thompson5910)
A student says that repeating decimals can not be multiplied together. How do you... (answered by jim_thompson5910)
A student says that – 4 – 3 (9) is the same as – 7 (9). How do you... (answered by Mathtut)