SOLUTION: Your class has just completed a unit on divisibility rules. One of the students ask why divisibility by numbers other than 3 and 9 can not be tested by dividing the sum of the dig

Question 174065: Your class has just completed a unit on divisibility rules. One of the students ask why divisibility by numbers other than 3 and 9 can not be tested by dividing the sum of the digits by the tested number. How do you respond?
Answer by Mathtut(3670) (Show Source): You can put this solution on YOUR website!

I should think the answer is obvious since the student just completed a unit on the divisibility rules. That is like a student just finishing a unit on the pathagorean theorem and that same student asking why doesnt the theorem work on a circle...WHY because it just doesnt . I dont know who comes up with some of these questions....This one is useless imo
:
but here is an attempt at an explanation:
:
You can see why if you go back to how the rule of adding the digits to test for divisibility by 3 (or 9) was derived:
First, if several different numbers are all divisible by 3, then their sum is also divisible by 3.
Second, any number multiplied by a number that is divisible by 3 is also divisible by 3.
Third, say you have a 3 digit number 'xyz'. This can be written as:
100x + 10y + z
= (99x + x) + (9y + y) + z
= 99x + 9y + (x + y + z)
which is x+y+z=99x+9y
The point of that is that if we subtract out the sum of the digits from a number, we're always left with something that's divisible by 9 (and therefore also divisble by 3) because it's in the form (99*x + 9*y), or for larger numbers 999 times something, 9999 times something, etc. But not so for other numbers.
You're probably familiar with the rule for testing divisibility by 2 or 5: just look at the rightmost digit. It's really the same principle but with less algebraic manipulation. Again as with the 3-digit number 'xyz', you have:
100*x + 10*y + z
Of course the 100*x and 10*y parts are divisble by 2 and 5, so all you have to do is pull out the last digit 'z' and test its divisibility.

RELATED QUESTIONS
Your class has just completed a unit on divisibility rules. One of the students asks why (answered by rajagopalan)
Your class has just completed a unit on divisibility rules. One of the students asks why (answered by bob123132)
the sum of the digits of a large number is 15. using the divisibility rules by which... (answered by KMST)
Test each of these numbers for divisibility by 3, 5, and 11 without using a calculator:... (answered by Fombitz)
what are the divisibility rules from 14 to 100? (answered by CharStar)
What is the divisibility of... (answered by scoop,Prithwis)
what is the divisibility of... (answered by stanbon)
what is the divisibility of 5__1=3... (answered by ikleyn)