SOLUTION: Claire's brother is 3 years older than her. Her mother is 4 times older than her. Their combined age is 57. By constructing an equation, calculate how old her brother is

Question 1101153: Claire's brother is 3 years older than her. Her mother is 4 times older than her. Their combined age is 57. By constructing an equation, calculate how old her brother is
Found 2 solutions by greenestamps, Alan3354:
Answer by greenestamps(13200) (Show Source): You can put this solution on YOUR website!

With the problem as stated, there is no solution, because the ages all turn out to be mixed numbers. Age problems should have solutions that are positive integers.

The difficulty is in the statement that Claire's mother is 4 times older than Claire. "4 times older than x" means x, plus x 4 more times, or 5x. But trying to solve the problem that way gives ages that are not whole numbers.

So the statement of the problem should say that Claire's mother is 4 times AS OLD AS Claire -- not 4 times older.

Once we have gotten past the incorrect statement of the problem, we have
x = Claire's age
x+3 = her brother's age
4x = her mother's age

Then since the sum of the ages is 57,

The brother's age is 9+3 = 12.
Answer by Alan3354(69443) (Show Source): You can put this solution on YOUR website!
It seems the authors of math problems don't know the difference between "4 times older" and "4 times as old." I suggest they get a different job.
=================
I've seen "10 times closer." What can that mean? 1 time closer --> no distance between the objects.
And "10 times smaller."
Ignorance is rampant.
Avoid it.
RELATED QUESTIONS
Sam�s brother is 7 years older than Sam. His mother is 4 less than 3 times Sam�s age.... (answered by ewatrrr)
Sandra's brother is 6 years older than her, her sister is 2 years younger than her, and... (answered by sachi)
A girl is three years older than her brother. If their combined age is 35 years, how old... (answered by MathLover1)
isabel is 5 years older than her brother. their mothers age is two less than three times... (answered by VFBundy)
Janet is X, her brother is 3 years older than her. Find the sum of their... (answered by lenny460)
Holly is x years old. Her brother is 4 years older than holly. Her father is 3 times... (answered by Alan3354)
Mary is 6 years older than her brother. Mary�s brother is 4 years older than their... (answered by josgarithmetic)
sams brother is 7 years older than sam. his mother is 4 years less than 3 times sams age. (answered by hussamuddin)
Sharon's sister is 9 years older than her. Their combined age is 35. How old is Sharon's... (answered by Alan3354)