Let the total number of pens be x 1st student takes x/3 2nd student also takes x/3 Remaining is (x - x/3 - x/3) = x/3 3rd student takes 1/3rd of this, i.e. x/9 Number of pens taken = x/3 + x/3 + x/9 = 7*x/9 Remaining = x - 7*x/9 = 2*x/9 This is divided evenly amongst the 3, so each gets 2*x/(9*3) = 2*x/27 For this to be a whole number, x has to be a multiple of 27. The smallest value of x that satisfies this is, of course, 27. So the smallest number of pens that satisfies the conditions is 27. Check: 1st person gets 9 2nd student gets 9 Remaining 9 3rd students takes 1/3rd = 3 Total taken = 9 + 9 + 3 = 21 Remaining 6 Divided equally among the 3, each gets 2. Note: 27 is the *least* number that satisfies the conditions. Take any multiple of 27, those work for the conditions as well. e.g. 54, 81, 108. So actually this problem has infinite number of solutions. :)