SOLUTION: A student claims that the equation 5x = 4x is a contradiction, since dividing both sides by x leads to 5 = 4, a false statement. Explain why the student is incorrect.

Question 94892: A student claims that the equation 5x = 4x is a contradiction, since dividing both sides by x leads to 5 = 4, a false statement. Explain why the student is incorrect.
Answer by bucky(2189) (Show Source): You can put this solution on YOUR website!
Because if x equals zero the equation becomes:
.
5*0 = 4*0
.
and this reduces to:
.
0 = 0
.
and this is true. (And if x is allowed to equal zero, you cannot divide both sides by
x because division by zero is not allowed.)
.
So there you have an exception to what the student proposed, so the student is incorrect.
.
Hope this makes sense to you.

RELATED QUESTIONS
5X-5=0 This is a linear equation since the largest exponent on the variable is 1. 1.... (answered by TutorMiriam)

1. Q > ~Q 2. ~(G & Q) > U / ~(G & ~U) Can somebody solve this proof please? Thank you (answered by jim_thompson5910)

Solve the equation. If it is an identity (all real numbers) or a contradiction(no... (answered by jim_thompson5910)

I need to solve for x on the following equations. I honestly don't know what to do.... (answered by fcabanski)

can someone tell me how to answer this question? please A student claims that the... (answered by stanbon)

Solve the equation. If it is an identity (all real numbers) or a contradiction (no... (answered by josmiceli)

Solve for x E r |1-2x|=3 Since I would be dividing both sides by a negative when... (answered by tommyt3rd)

Solve the equation. If it is an identity (all real numbers) or a contradiction (no... (answered by stanbon)

A Student claims that the equations sq -x =3 has no solution since the square root of a... (answered by gonzo)