We have to be careful here! We might be tempted to use the zero-factor principle. However that will lead us astray because is not defined at ANY of the values of x for which ! So do NOT do this: Instead use the identity to replace . We can cancel 's as long as we are careful not to allow any values of x which cause the denominator to be zero. That leaves: which has solution , where n is any integer. And this is a valid solution since is always either or , and never . Edwin