The other tutor's solution is incorrect. While it is true that the perimeter must be even, that is not enough information. The sides are 20, n, and n. Every triangle must be such that (its first side) + (its second side) > (its third side) (its first side) + (its third side) > (its second side) (its second side) + (its third side) > (its first side) Let its first side = 20, its second side be n and its third side be n Then we must have: 20 + n > n 20 + n > n n + n > 20 or 20 > 0 20 > 0 2n > 20 The first two inequalities are always true, and the last inequality 2n > 20 is true whenever n > 10 The smallest integer n could be such that n > 10 is n = 11 So the sides of the triangle with smallest possible perimeter are 20, 11 and 11, so the smallest perimeter is 20+11+11=42 Edwin