SOLUTION: Circular logic? (H). Take a Golden Rectangle and draw the largest circle inside it that touches three sides. The circle will touch two opposite sides of the rectangle. If we conn

Algebra.Com
Question 1113279: Circular logic? (H). Take a Golden Rectangle and draw the largest circle
inside it that touches three sides. The circle will touch two opposite sides
of the rectangle. If we connect those two points with a line and then cut
the rectangle into two pieces along that line, will either of the two
smaller rectangles be a Golden Rectangle? Explain your reasoning.

Answer by Edwin McCravy(20056)   (Show Source): You can put this solution on YOUR website!
The answer to problem as stated is no.  However there is a
similar problem to which the answer is yes. First the problem
as stated is no:

This figure below is drawn to scale. The longer side of the
large rectangle is  times the shorter
side.

  

All golden rectangles are similar.  So the answer is 
no, because neither of those two rectangles is similar
to the large rectangle.

-------------------------------

Now here is a similar problem where the answer is yes.
We draw the line different: 

Take a Golden Rectangle and draw the largest circle
inside it that touches three sides. If we draw a line
parallel to the shorter side and tangent to the circle
and then cut the rectangle into two pieces along that
line, will either of the two smaller rectangles be a
Golden Rectangle?
The big rectangle below is Golden.  The short side is "a"
and the long side is .  The circle is inscribed
in a square. The bottom side of the square is "a" units
So the short side of the small rectangle on the right is 
 

 
      |------------------------------------------|
                          

Now we will show that the small rectangle on the right is golden.

The ratio of the sides is



Divide numerator and denominator by a



Substitute 



Multiply top and bottom by 2







Rationalize the denominator by multiplying by 









Divide top and bottom by -2:



Which is , the golden ratio.

So for this problem, the answer is 

Yes, the small rectangle on the right is golden.

[I have a hunch this was the problem that was intended.
Point this out to your teacher.]

Edwin


RELATED QUESTIONS

I have a perfect circle inscribed inside of a perfect square where the sides of the... (answered by venugopalramana)
what is the largest diameter circle that will fit inside a regular pentagon with 2-inch... (answered by ikleyn)
What is the radius of the largest circle that will fit inside a triangle that has two... (answered by ikleyn)
Find the area of the largest rectangle that fits inside a circle of radius 10. (answered by greenestamps)
draw the outer circle of raius 3cm.then draw six identical smaller circles touches it... (answered by Fombitz)
what size rectangle will fit inside a circle of radius 30 feet if the lenght of the... (answered by KMST)
the largest possible circle is drawn inside a... (answered by Alan3354)
what is the area of the largest circle that can be drawn inside a rectangle that is 8 cm... (answered by richwmiller)
what is the largest area of the circle can be drawn inside a rectangle of length and... (answered by richwmiller)