Factor the top and bottom: Now as long as you do not cancel the (x+4)'s, then x cannot equal to -4, because if you substitute x = -4, you get: That is undefined, because we cannot divide anything by 0, not even 0 divided by 0. It's simply undefined. That's what causes the hole to be in the graph. Now if we cancel the (x+4)'s we get a graph which has no hole. Its graph does NOT have a hole! Notice that if we substitute x=-4 in it, we get: So the graph goes through the point So the graph of whih has no hole, is this: That's the graph WITHOUT the hole because the point is there, indicated by the darkened circle. Now let's go back to the original equation, which has a hole, because the (x+4)'s were not canceled: Its graph is the same as the graph of except that it has a hole and doesn't go through the point . Its graph is: So when you leave the equation as it was given originally, And do not factor and cancel out the (x+4)'s then you have a hole at the point that makes (x+4) equal to 0. Then when you factor and cancel the (x+4)'s, you "fill in" the hole. There is a hole when you don't cancel, and no hole when you do cancel. Edwin