SOLUTION: Could you please help me with this equation? The solution manual says the answer is x=1 but I am getting x = 1 and x= - 4. Could you please help me understand why - 4 is not a so

Algebra.Com
Question 1196335: Could you please help me with this equation? The solution manual says the answer is x=1 but I am getting x = 1 and x= - 4.
Could you please help me understand why - 4 is not a solution? I checked it and it doesn't seem to be an extraneous solution. Would be a huge help if you could please include an explanation for the steps.
Would greatly appreciate your help.
IMG-4646

Found 2 solutions by josgarithmetic, ikleyn:
Answer by josgarithmetic(39617)   (Show Source): You can put this solution on YOUR website!
You want to know why -4 is not a solution.

Did you try to test this value?

Work with that and see what happens.

Answer by ikleyn(52778)   (Show Source): You can put this solution on YOUR website!
.

It is  BECAUSE  if you substitute  x= -4  into left side expression,

you will get the number under square root   (-4)^2 +5*(-4) = 16 - 20 = -4.

But negative numbers are not allowed under square root - - - THEREFORE,  we  REJECT   x= - 4.

The same is with the right side expression:  it does not allow  x= -4.

So,  x= -4  is an extraneous solution.


Hope,  everything is clear now.



RELATED QUESTIONS

[ I am reposting because there was a typo in my email when I posted the previous question (answered by josgarithmetic,math_tutor2020)
Ahhhh, I am a pretty good math student and this question is probably not something I will (answered by Edwin McCravy)
Hi, Could you please help me with this question? {{{ log (x+1, (x-1)) = 2 }}} What... (answered by Alan3354)
Could someone help with this problem: Find the exact solution, and a two-decimal-place (answered by Alan3354)
Hi, I need some help understanding this absolute value inequality function. I don't... (answered by ikleyn,josgarithmetic,MathTherapy)
I could use some help with this problem please. Solve for X x/x-2 - x+1/x =... (answered by Nate)
HI! Could you help me with this equation, thank you sOo much!... (answered by maribeth_abella)
I am trying to graph the equation of F(x)-= (3/2)^x The line I am getting is wavy and... (answered by Mathtut)
I am struggling with some of my Algebra problems. Could you please help me with this... (answered by jim_thompson5910)