We plot those three points:And now we can sketch the ellipse: and draw 'a' and 'b'. We can tell that a=4 and b=2 by counting units: The equation is Since f(x,y) , The above graph is a cross section of a 3D eliptic paraboloid, when sliced at the plane where z=1. We are to find f(x,0) f(x,y) and f(x,0) f(x,0) f(x,0) f(x,0) That is a parabola which is a cross section of the same 3D elliptic paraboloid when sliced by the xz-plane. Edwin