1. D v C 2. C > (F v D) 3. ~F conclusion: D ------------------------------------------------------- 4. ~~C > (F v D) 2 Double Negation 5. ~C v (F v D) 4 Material Implication 6. ~C v (D v F) 5 Commutation 7. (~C v D) v F 6 Association 8. (C > D) v F 7 Material Implication 9. F v (C > D) 8 Commutation 10. ~~F v (C > D) 9 Double Negation 11. C > D 10,3 Disjunctive Syllogism 12. ~~D v C 1 Double Negation 13. ~D > C 12 Material Implication 14. ~D > D 13,11 Hypothetical Syllogism 15. ~~D v D 14 Material Implication 16. D v D 15 Double Negation 17. D 16 Tautology