1. ~(P & F) 2. ((W v L) -> P) & W 3. L -> F -------------------------------------- 4. W & ((W v L) -> P) 2 Commutation 5. W 4 Simplification 6. W v L 5 Addition 7. (W v L) -> P 2 Simplification 8. P 7,6 Modus Ponens 9. ~~P 8 Double Negation 10. ~P v ~F 1 De Morgan's Law 11. ~F 10,9 Disjunctive Syllogism 12. ~L 3,11 Modus Tollens