1. ( R * S) v (R * ~E) Pr. 2. (Y * O) -> (E * ~S) Pr. 3. (O -> ~Y) -> L Pr. / .: L ------------------------------------------------- 4. R * (S v ~E) 1 Distribution 5. (S v ~E) * R 4 Commutation 6. S v ~E 5 Simplification 7. ~E v S 6 Commutation 8. ~E v ~~S 7 Double Negation 9. ~(E * ~S) 8 De Morgan's Law 10. ~(Y * O) 2,9 Modus Tollens 11. ~Y v ~O 10 De Morgan's Law 12. ~O v ~Y 11 Commutation 13. O -> ~Y 12 Material Implication 14. L 3,13 Modus Ponens