1. (p v q) -> r 2. r -> (s <--> t) 3. s -> ~t Therefore: ~p v ~t ------------------------------- 4. r -> [ (s -> t) & (t -> s) ] 2 Material Equivalence 5. ~r v [ (s -> t) & (t -> s) ] 4 Material Implication 6. [~r v (s -> t)] & [~r v (t -> s)] 5 Distribution 7. [~r v (t -> s)] & [~r v (s -> t)] 6 Commutation 8. ~r v (t -> s) 7 Simplification 9. r -> (t -> s) 8 Material Implication 10. (r & t) -> s 9 Exportation 11. (r & t) -> ~t 3,10 Hypothetical Syllogism 12. r -> (t -> ~t) 11 Exportation 13. r -> (~t v ~t) 12 Material Implication 14. r -> ~t 13 Tautology 15. (p v q) -> ~t 1,14 Hypothetical Syllogism 16. ~(p v q) v ~t 15 Material Implication 17. (~p & ~q) v ~t 16 DeMorgan's Theorem 18. ~t v (~p & ~q) 17 Commutation 19. (~t v ~p) & (~t v ~q) 18 Distribution 20. ~t v ~p 19 Simplification 21. ~p v ~t 20 Commutation