1. ~(J * L) 2. (J --> ~L) --> (~M * ~X) 3. E v (M v X). .·. E 4. ~J v ~L 1, DeMorgan's law 5. J --> ~L 4, Material Implication 6. ~M * ~X 2,5, Modus Ponens 7. ~(M v X) 6, DeMorgan's law 8. (M v X) v E 3, Commutation 9. E 8,7 Disjunctive Syllogism Edwin