Number | Statement | Lines Used | Reason | |
---|---|---|---|---|
:. | P -> (~P -> (Q <-> (R v S))) | |||
1 | P | ACP | ||
2 | ~~P | 1 | DN | |
3 | ~~P v (P -> (Q <-> (R v S))) | 2 | Add | |
4 | ~P -> (P -> (Q <-> (R v S))) | 3 | MI | |
5 | (~P & P) -> (Q <-> (R v S)) | 4 | Exp | |
6 | (P & ~P) -> (Q <-> (R v S)) | 5 | Comm | |
7 | P -> (~P -> (Q <-> (R v S))) | 6 | Exp | |
8 | P -> {P -> (~P -> (Q <-> (R v S)))} | 1-7 | CP | |
9 | (P & P) -> (~P -> (Q <-> (R v S))) | 8 | Exp | |
10 | P -> (~P -> (Q <-> (R v S))) | 9 | Taut |
Number | Statement | Lines Used | Reason | |
---|---|---|---|---|
:. | P -> (~P -> (Q <-> (R v S))) | |||
1 | ~[P -> (~P -> (Q <-> (R v S)))] | AIP | ||
2 | ~[~P v (~P -> (Q <-> (R v S)))] | 1 | MI | |
3 | ~[~P v (~~P v (Q <-> (R v S)))] | 2 | MI | |
4 | ~[~P v (P v (Q <-> (R v S)))] | 3 | DN | |
5 | ~[(~P v P) v (Q <-> (R v S))] | 4 | Assoc | |
6 | ~(~P v P) & ~(Q <-> (R v S)) | 5 | DM | |
7 | ~(~P v P) | 6 | Simp | |
8 | ~~P & ~P | 7 | DM | |
9 | P & ~P | 8 | DN | |
10 | P -> (~P -> (Q <-> (R v S))) | 1-9 | IP |